Hi all,

While preparing the Roller 7.0.0 release candidate, I updated our LICENSE and 
NOTICE files to match what 7.0.0 actually ships:

https://github.com/apache/roller/pull/265

Three questions came up that I'd like the PMC's input on before we cut RC1, 
since release voters check these files.

1. Category B files in the source release

Two sets of checked-in files are under Category B licenses:

- Font Awesome 3.2.1 font files (SIL OFL 1.1) in 
app/src/main/webapp/themes/gaurav/font/
- The Silk icons (CC BY 2.5) in app/src/main/webapp/images/ and 
themes/{fauxcoly,gaurav}/icons/

Because they're checked in, they end up in the source archive. ASF policy 
allows Category B works in binary form only 
(https://www.apache.org/legal/resolved.html). Should we remove them from the 
source tree and replace them (for example with Bootstrap Icons, which the admin 
UI already uses), or is there a justification we can rely on for keeping them? 
PR #265 labels them for now rather than removing them.

2. Files with no recorded license or source

- searchhi.js, from kryogenix.org (Stuart Langridge), in themes/fauxcoly/, 
themes/gaurav/js/ and theme/scripts/. It has no license statement.
- Some smileys, editor GIFs and brand logos in themes/*/icons, which date from 
the 2005 initial import and have no recorded source.

Does anyone know where these came from, or should we replace them?

3. The "RSS and Atom in Action" line in NOTICE

NOTICE.txt credits "snippets of code written by Dave Johnson for RSS and Atom 
in Action" (Copyright 2005 David M Johnson), but I couldn't find code that 
clearly carries it anymore. Dave, do you know whether any of that code is still 
in Roller, or can we drop the line?

Thanks,

Matt

Reply via email to