My overwhelming concern with this is what happens to the users in the field who depend on slider but don't foresee migrating to Hadoop 3.x any time soon. Given the size of the 3.x changes and the likely disruption to operations that such a migration would cause for a Hadoop cluster of any significant size, I can only imagine that this will matter to a significant number of slider users.
-david On 4/20/18, 12:55 PM, Billie Rinaldi <billie.rina...@gmail.com> wrote: Dear Slider Community, Activity on Slider has been very low for about a year and we have received feedback from the IPMC that it is time for us to figure out where the project is going. Also, an AM implementation that supports long running services has now been released in Apache Hadoop YARN 3.1.0. Let's start a discussion on whether it is time to retire the Slider podling. Here is some information about what retirement means and what the retirement process looks like: http://incubator.apache.org/guides/retirement.html Billie