Hi, I've looked on the specification and I've noticed that it also overlaps with the Karaf Feature functionality.
Is there any relation between the two? Is there collaboration between the projects? As a user/consumer of technology I enjoy when technologies are compatible and the tooling support is great. I believe collaboration in this area is beneficial. I would like to be able to provision Sling features in Karaf and Karaf features in Sling with ease. If you put the spec side by side they share a LOT of things, but there are also some minor differences, like file format. Karaf uses XML which has much better tooling support IMO, but this is a persistence format and can be easily changed. p.s. I like the spec, I imagine it took quite some time to write. Kudos ! Regards, [1] https://karaf.apache.org/manual/latest/provisioning On 21.02.2018 09:10, Carsten Ziegeler wrote: > Thanks David > > We're neither 100% clear on the requirements nor on the structure, > meaning we don't know how many and what modules this will be. As we're > following the one module per git repo rule, it's currently impossible to > create the correct git repositories. And I guess it doesn't make sense > to rename them or remove them every now and then. > > As the collaboration with the whiteboard is the same as with separate > modules, I don't think there is anything wrong with having this in the > whiteboard for now. Moving it out now creates more problems than it solves. > > Regards > > Carsten > > > David Bosschaert wrote >> Hi all, >> >> Over the recent past some additions have been made to the requirements of >> the Sling Feature Model. The updated requirements can be found here: >> https://github.com/apache/sling-whiteboard/blob/master/featuremodel/readme.md >> >> Any additional requirements, let us know! >> >> I'm hoping to start contributing to the implementation of some of these in >> the near term and was wondering - is there a reason why the feature model >> still in the sling-whiteboard? Or would it make sense to put it in its own >> Sling git repo or repos? >> >> Best regards, >> >> David >>
signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature
