Speaking of tickets, there's one already open * http://issues.apache.org/struts/browse/WW-
-Ted. On 12/14/06, Don Brown <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:
Very interesting... I wonder how much of the performance hit was due to Freemarker and how much OGNL. Could you package this application in a war and attach it to a JIRA ticket? I'd love to have it for future comparisons. Don dice wrote: > They are my stats Ted. The stats are posted below along with my sample JSP > code. I only tried the textfield tag but looking at the ftl and vm files for > the other tags I can't see how the results would be any different. > > Perhaps an interim solution could be to remove the use of OGNL from core > functionality that doesn't require it. eg. Is it really necessary to access > UIBean attributes from the theme templates using OGNL? > > PS: I emulated the Struts 2 themes in Struts 1 by wrapping Struts 1 tags in > JSP Tag files and performance was still impressive. > > > ---------------------------------------------------------------- > > Technology - Hits per second with 1 user / 10 users: > > Struts 1 - 109 / 191 > Stripes - 88 / 140 > WW2/SAF2 with default FreeMarker templates - 12 / 7 > WW2/SAF2 with Velocity templates - 22 / 15 > JSF - 27 / 40 > > > Sample JSP: > > <s:form action="/test.action" method="POST"> > <s:textfield label="Label1" name="attribute1"/> > <s:textfield label="Label2" name="attribute2"/> > <s:textfield label="Label3" name="attribute3"/> > <s:textfield label="Label4" name="attribute4"/> > <s:textfield label="Label5" name="attribute5"/> > <s:textfield label="Label6" name="attribute6"/> > <s:textfield label="Label7" name="attribute7"/> > <s:textfield label="Label8" name="attribute8"/> > <s:textfield label="Label9" name="attribute9"/> > <s:textfield label="Nested Label1" name="nestedBean.attribute1"/> > <s:textfield label="Nested Label2" name="nestedBean.attribute2"/> > <s:textfield label="Nested Label3" name="nestedBean.attribute3"/> > <s:textfield label="Nested Label4" name="nestedBean.attribute4"/> > <s:textfield label="Nested Label5" name="nestedBean.attribute5"/> > <s:textfield label="Nested Label6" name="nestedBean.attribute6"/> > <s:textfield label="Nested Label7" name="nestedBean.attribute7"/> > <s:textfield label="Nested Label8" name="nestedBean.attribute8"/> > <s:textfield label="Nested Label9" name="nestedBean.attribute9"/> > <s:submit/> > </s:form> > > > > Ted Husted-3 wrote: > >> On 12/13/06, Ian Roughley <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: >> >>> Do you have the performance numbers that you can share? I'd really be >>> interested in them. >>> >> There are some interesting numbers here >> >> * >> http://javajmc.blogspot.com/2006/10/webwork-and-stripes-simple-performance.html >> >> (be sure to read to the *end* of the commnets). >> >> We might want to come up with a set of test pages that thorougly >> exercise the core tags, so that we can run our own direct comparisons >> of S1, S2, et al. >> >> Of course, the peformance is the still same as WebWork 2, which is >> driving some serious applications. We also know exactly where lies the >> bottleneck. We need to fix or replace OGNL. >> >> -Ted. >> >> >> > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
-- HTH, Ted. * http://www.husted.com/struts/ --------------------------------------------------------------------- To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
