On Dec 6, 2007 1:27 PM, Martin Cooper <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote: > > Which security package(s) would you want to work with in addition to HDIV? > I > firmly believe that you need at least two candidates in order to > successfully design an SPI. Otherwise you run a very high risk of > designing > an SPI that can really only be successfully used by the one candidate you > designed it around. >
This is an excellent point. I have not considered this point of view before. I agree with your reasoning. > > A couple of other questions: > > * How does HDIV's editable content validation interact with the validation > mechanisms that we already have built into Struts? Is someone using HDIV > with Struts going to be writing their validations using HDIV's format, > Commons Validator's format, or both? > I think we should document this question on the wiki and whiteboard this idea. The makers of HDIV will be able to contribute answers there too. > > * How much of the functionality of HDIV is only available for people using > JSP with tag libraries? If I'm using Velocity, or not using server-side > presentation at all, how much of HDIV do I lose? > > Ditto. Paul
