[ http://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/subversion/trunk/notes/xfail-status ]
Paul Burba wrote on Tue, Feb 01, 2011 at 21:53:34 -0500: > Hi All, > > One of the roadmap items yet to be started was a 'test review' to > 'Determine which XFail and WIP tests should remain so, and which need > to be fixed before release.' > > I took a look at this today. And looks like you did a thorough job at that; thanks! > Keep in mind this is just a guess, if your name is there you aren't > compelled to do anything...though I suspect we'd all agree it's bad > form to create an XFailing test with no associated issue when we > aren't planning on fixing the underlying problem. > Sometimes I commit an XFail test that I have no immediate intention to work on myself; for example, just last week I committed two XFail tests which arrived as patch submissions. There are other legitimate reasons for adding XFail tests without immediatley working on a fix, I believe. > If you have some time please look through the list. If a test you > wrote needs an issue please write one up. If there is an existing > issue that should be associated with a test add it. If an associated > issue is unscheduled or never scheduled and you're familiar with it, > please take a stab at some issue triage. > LISTING: depth_tests.py > > Test # Mode Test Description > ------ ----- ---------------- > 36 XFAIL 'info' should treat excluded item as versioned > Issue #: None > Target Milestone: N/A > Thread: N/A > Log: r876772 > Point Person: danielsh Old bug. May not have an issue associated with it. I'll have a look, but it shouldn't block 1.7.0. > LISTING: prop_tests.py > > Test # Mode Test Description > ------ ----- ---------------- > 12 XFAIL set, get, and delete a revprop change > Issue #: 3086 > Target Milestone: 1.8-consider > Thread: N/A > Log: N/A > Point Person: Unassigned > > 26 XFAIL test handling invalid svn:* property values > Issue #: None > Target Milestone: N/A > Thread: N/A > Log: r871212 > Point Person: danielsh These two fail for the same reason --- something to do with pre-revprop-change hooks over ra_dav. In any case, feel free to cross #26 off your list; I'm sure it will be fixed as soon as #12 is.
We have lots of XFailing tests in our test suite and no easy way of telling which ones are release blockers. This is a first step to figuring out the answer to that question. LISTING: dirent_uri-test.exe Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 34 XFAIL test svn_dirent_get_absolute with lc drive Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: http://svn.haxx.se/dev/archive-2009-10/0682.shtml Log: r880444 Point Person: rhuijben LISTING: fs-test.exe Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 18 XFAIL (WIP) merging commit [[needs to be written to match new merge() algorithm expectations]] Issue #: N/A Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r875421 Point Person: cmpilato 36 XFAIL(WIP) obliterate 1 [[obliterate is in development]] Issue #: 516 Target Milestone: Unscheduled Thread: N/A Log: N/A Point Person: julianfoad LISTING: locks-test.exe Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 9 XFAIL able to reserve a name (lock non-existent path) Issue #: None Target Milestone: None Thread: N/A Log: r853631 Point Person: cmpilato 10 XFAIL directory locks (kinda) Issue #: None Target Milestone: None Thread: N/A Log: r853631 Point Person: cmpilato LISTING: parse-diff-test.exe Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 4 XFAIL test badly formatted git diff headers Issue #: None Target Milestone: None Thread: N/A Log: r960833 Point Person: dannas LISTING: stream-test.exe Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 6 XFAIL test stream seeking for translated streams Issue #: 3616 Target Milestone: 1.7.0 Thread: N/A Log: r936844 Point Person: stsp LISTING: authz_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 4 XFAIL (DAV and ra_svn only) test authz for read operations Issue #: 3242 Target Milestone: 1.6.13 (Status Resolved) Thread: N/A Log: r876530 Point Person: cmpilato 13 XFAIL (ra_svn only) authz issue #2712 Issue #: 2712 Target Milestone: Unscheduled Thread: N/A Log: N/A Point Person: None (vgeorgescu is assigned the issue, but appears inactive). 14 XFAIL (DAV and ra_svn only) switched to directory, no read access on parents Issue #: None Target Milestone: None Thread: N/A Log: r867298 Point Person: lgo LISTING: basic_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 39 XFAIL remotely remove directories from two repositories Issue #: 1199 Target Milestone: Unscheduled Thread: N/A Log: N/A Point Person: Unassigned LISTING: commit_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 25 XFAIL commit from two nested working copies Issue #: 2381 Target Milestone: 1.7-consider Thread: http://svn.haxx.se/dev/archive-2009-05/0509.shtml Log: r878104 Point Person: stsp (Issue was assigned to GSoC student Hui Huang). 26 XFAIL commit from two working copies Issue #: 2381 Target Milestone: 1.7-consider Thread: http://svn.haxx.se/dev/archive-2009-05/0509.shtml Log: r878104 Point Person: stsp (Issue was assigned to GSoC student Hui Huang). LISTING: copy_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 24 XFAIL wc to wc copy with deleted=true items Issue #: 2101, 2020 Target Milestone: Unscheduled (But both issues marked as resolved). Thread: N/A Log: r879708, r959450 Point Person: philip, gstein 80 XFAIL commit only top of copy; check child behavior Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: None Log: r927469 Point Person: rhuijben 86 XFAIL changed dir after commit should match checkout Issue #: 3676 Target Milestone: --- Thread: N/A Log: r961831 Point Person: rhuijben 89 XFAIL copy mixed-rev and delete children Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r1004629 Point Person: philip 91 XFAIL copy, delete child, revert copy Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r1027031 Point Person: philip LISTING: depth_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 36 XFAIL 'info' should treat excluded item as versioned Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r876772 Point Person: danielsh LISTING: diff_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 49 XFAIL diff URL against working copy with local mods Issue #: 3295 Target Milestone: --- Thread: N/A Log: r873641 Point Person: neels 50 XFAIL diff -r1 of dir with removed-then-readded file Issue #: 1675 Target Milestone: Unscheduled (Issue is marked as RESOLVED). Thread: N/A Log: r873641 Point Person: neels LISTING: export_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 11 XFAIL export working copy at base revision Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r980465 Point Person: julianfoad 20 XFAIL exporting a file refuses to silently overwrite Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r1037998 Point Person: danielsh 24 XFAIL export working copy with different depths Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r980497 Point Person: julianfoad LISTING: externals_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 19 XFAIL delete a file external Issue #: 3351 Target Milestone: --- Thread: N/A Log: 876918 Point Person: neels LISTING: lock_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 32 XFAIL verify unlocking with wrong lock token Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: None Log: r858765, r869893 Point Person: None (test was committed by lundblad) 34 XFAIL unlock file locked by other user Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: None Log: r865614 Point Person: lgo 39 XFAIL test replace + propset of locked file Issue #: 3674 Target Milestone: --- Thread: N/A Log: r961442 Point Person: cmpilato LISTING: merge_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 49 XFAIL avoid repeated merges for cyclic merging Issue #: 2897 Target Milestone: 1.7-consider Thread: N/A Log: r865371 Point Person: kameshj/pburba 64 XFAIL merge target with non inheritable mergeinfo Issue #: 2970 Target Milestone: 1.8-consider Thread: N/A Log: N/A Point Person: pburba 75 XFAIL merge added subtree Issue #: 1962 Target Milestone: 1.7-consider Thread: N/A Log: r876983 Point Person: Unassigned 115 XFAIL don't inherit bogus working mergeinfo Issue #: 3756 Target Milestone: 1.8.0 Thread: N/A Log: N/A Point Person: pburba LISTING: merge_tree_conflict_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 12 XFAIL tree conflicts 5.1: leaf edit, tree del Issue #: 2282 Target Milestone: 1.8-consider Thread: N/A Log: N/A Point Person: Unassigned 13 XFAIL tree conflicts 5.2: leaf del, tree del Issue #: 2282 Target Milestone: 1.8-consider Thread: N/A Log: N/A Point Person: Unassigned 18 XFAIL tree conflicts 5.2: leaf del (no ci), tree del Issue #: 2282 Target Milestone: 1.8-consider Thread: N/A Log: N/A Point Person: Unassigned 22 XFAIL replace vs. edit tree-conflicts Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r879723 Point Person: julianfoad 23 XFAIL replace vs. delete tree-conflicts Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r879162 Point Person: neels LISTING: mergeinfo_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 4 XFAIL 'mergeinfo' with uninteresting source selection Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r874947 Point Person: pburba LISTING: patch_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 29 XFAIL patch doesn't append newline to properties Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r1033709 Point Person: danielsh LISTING: prop_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 12 XFAIL set, get, and delete a revprop change Issue #: 3086 Target Milestone: 1.8-consider Thread: N/A Log: N/A Point Person: Unassigned 26 XFAIL test handling invalid svn:* property values Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r871212 Point Person: danielsh LISTING: resolve_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 2 XFAIL resolving prop conflicts Issue #: 3707 Target Milestone: --- Thread: N/A Log: r995848 Point Person: pburba LISTING: revert_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 4 XFAIL revert a moved file Issue #: 876 Target Milestone: Unscheduled Thread: N/A Log: N/A Point Person: Unassigned LISTING: stat_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 32 XFAIL status on wc with nested old-format wc Issue #: 3742 Target Milestone: 1.7.0 Thread: N/A Log: r1027732 Point Person: Unassigned LISTING: switch_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 10 XFAIL switch a file to a dir and back to the file Issue #: 1532 Target Milestone: 1.7-consider Thread: N/A Log: r847437 Point Person: Unassigned 21 XFAIL forced switch detects tree conflicts Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r875936 Point Person: pburba 38 XFAIL copy directory with switched subdir Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r879627 Point Person: rhuijben LISTING: tree_conflict_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 8 XFAIL (DAV Only) up/sw dir: add onto add Issue #: 3314 Target Milestone: --- Thread: N/A Log: r875902 Point Person: Unassigned 14 XFAIL merge dir: del/rpl/mv onto not-same Issue #: 3150 Target Milestone: 1.7.0 Thread: N/A Log: http://svn.apache.org/viewvc?view=revision&revision=871446 Point Person: Unassigned 17 XFAIL --force del on dir with TCs inside Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r878027 Point Person: neels 18 XFAIL --force del on tree-conflicted targets Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r878028 Point Person: neels 20 XFAIL issue #3608: reverting an add onto add conflict Issue #: 3608 Target Milestone: --- Thread: N/A Log: r927112 Point Person: rhuijben 21 XFAIL lock status update shouldn't flag tree conflict Issue #: 3525 and 3533 Target Milestone: 1.7-consider (3525) and --- (3533) Thread: N/A Log: r954016 Point Person: Unassigned LISTING: update_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 47 XFAIL tree conflicts 2.3: skip on 2nd update Issue #: 3329 Target Milestone: 1.7-consider Thread: N/A Log: N/A Point Person: Unassigned 50 XFAIL tree conflicts on update UC2, schedule re-add Issue #: 3334 Target Milestone: Unscheduled Thread: N/A Log: N/A Point Person: julianfoad 53 XFAIL verify update of deleted locked files Issue #: 3525 Target Milestone: 1.7-consider Thread: N/A Log: N/A Point Person: Unassigned 54 XFAIL svn up --depth empty hides entries for next update Issue #: 3569 Target Milestone: Unscheduled Thread: N/A Log: N/A Point Person: Unassigned 57 XFAIL update with file lock & keywords property set Issue #: 3471 Target Milestone: Thread: http://subversion.tigris.org/ds/viewMessage.do? dsForumId=1065&dsMessageId=2385406 Log: r995388 Point Person: Unassigned 58 XFAIL update a nonexistent child of a copied dir Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: None Log: r1035347 Point Person: julianfoad LISTING: upgrade_tests.py Test # Mode Test Description ------ ----- ---------------- 8 XFAIL 3x same wc upgrade 1.4.0 test Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r959804 Point Person: rhuijben 13 XFAIL check status delete and delete --keep-local Issue #: None Target Milestone: N/A Thread: N/A Log: r991512 Point Person: rhuijben
