Nathan Hartman wrote:
Would someone who has a LinkedIn account be kind enough to post a very polite request for testimonials there?

Also, would it be appropriate and acceptable to post this request to our own users@ list?

I say yes.

It was said recently (as well as long ago), on the Svn PMC's [1] private mailing list, that a press release (PR) should be organized in private so it makes a "splash" (a surprise) to maximize impact in the press. I understand the intent behind that, from the marketing point of view, but in this open community I place higher value on publicly involving community members who are not members of the PMC. If that results in lower "splash" value, that's fine: community over PR.

Still, while publicly soliciting testimonials (and any other ideas), we can minimize the dilution effect by collecting them and drafting the text in private: the press shouldn't be finding the whole thing is previously published. Let's be open that that's what we're doing, and endeavour to include any non-PMC-members who wish to be included. (If someone wants to be included in that part, e.g. seeing the draft, please say and we'll work to find a satisfactory way to include you.)

To that end, let's ask that contacts send their actual quotes to private@ in the first place. Nathan is co-ordinating the drafting and any privately solicited quotes there anyway, aren't you?

- Julian


[1] PMC: the project management committee, roughly equals "committers",
    https://www.apache.org/foundation/governance/pmcs

Reply via email to