On Sat, Jun 6, 2015 at 10:23 PM, Varnau, Steve (Trafodion) < [email protected]> wrote:
> Comment below... .... > > > > This will split the comment history across two systems. > > Apache Infra provides integration with github, such that all the github > pull-request activity is mirrored back to JIRA. Jira is the system of > record. Github provides a better code-review interface than Jira, so it is > convenient to make code review comments there. Apache/Spark and other > projects use similar process. > > The thread I cite was explicitly about difficulty being able to search pulls in Spark. If JIRA "is the system of record" and pull-request back and forth shows in JIRA, then that sounds good; my concern is addressed. > The Apache CI system does not have any RedHat/Centos systems as far as we > can tell, so we'd need to continue running them elsewhere. Again, I believe > Spark and other projects do as well. > > I like the Roman suggestion in a subsequent message, that T8 do docker; it would seem to make sense particularly in your case given the list of dependencies required. > One key is that each pull-request in github should have a JIRA-ID in the > title. Committers should not discuss/merge something that doesn't. > > Sounds good Steve, St.Ack > -Steve > > > > > > > > > > From the development point of view, everyone would need a github > > > account, rather than gerrit account. The workflow would be to do work > > > on a branch, push the branch to their fork on github, then make a > > > pull-request on github. I'll provide some detailed instructions on the > > > wiki. In order to facilitate working with github, I recommend folks > > > use the git wrapper tool call "hub": https://hub.github.com/ > > > > > > Details to come, but I wanted to start the discussion whether this is > > > the right direction. > > > > > > > > The pull request would come into the apache dev list and then a > > committer would apply it with back and forth between contributor and > > committer happening in github -- rather than in Apache INFRA JIRA or > > review board? > > > > Would this process have a "dark side" if looking in from an Apache view > > only? Patches would show up in dev as pull requests and be committed > > without comment because all discussion had happened already elsewhere. > > > > St.Ack > > > > > > > > > -Steve > > > > > > > > > > > > >
