[
https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/UIMA-1860?page=com.atlassian.jira.plugin.system.issuetabpanels:all-tabpanel
]
Marshall Schor updated UIMA-1860:
---------------------------------
Description:
Write more test cases examining behavior regarding type/subtype inheritance for
both features and types in result specs, and language subsumption testing,
using both containsType or containsFeature, with and without intersection.
Issues found include:
* Supertype with allFeatures sets allFeatures for all subtypes. Correct
behavior: specifying allFeatures on a type should only imply allFeatures for
features that are known for that type. Features introduced only in subtypes
should not be included.
* -Serialization/deserialization ignores languages other than x-unspecified; it
should support the full result-specification. potential (future?) use case:
sending result specs to remote delegates.- This was due to a misinterpretation
of a javadoc comment. The getResultTypesAndFeatures() (with no arguments)
previously was defined to skip any language tests when retreiving the types and
features. This is quite different from filtering only those with language
x-unspecified. Make sure any rework keeps this behavior. That being said, the
extracted types and features are missing any language information.
* Assume a feature F introduced in a supertype T. A result spec T:F should be
sufficient to return true for a test of T2:F, where T2 is a subtype ot T
(currently returns false).
was:
Write more test cases examining behavior regarding type/subtype inheritance for
both features and types in result specs, and language subsumption testing,
using both containsType or containsFeature, with and without intersection.
Issues found include:
* Supertype with allFeatures sets allFeatures for all subtypes. Correct
behavior: specifying allFeatures on a type should only imply allFeatures for
features that are known for that type. Features introduced only in subtypes
should not be included.
* Serialization/deserialization ignores languages other than x-unspecified; it
should support the full result-specification. potential (future?) use case:
sending result specs to remote delegates.
* Assume a feature F introduced in a supertype T. A result spec T:F should be
sufficient to return true for a test of T2:F, where T2 is a subtype ot T
(currently returns false).
> ResultSpec behavior incorrect in several cases
> ----------------------------------------------
>
> Key: UIMA-1860
> URL: https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/UIMA-1860
> Project: UIMA
> Issue Type: Bug
> Components: Core Java Framework
> Reporter: Marshall Schor
> Assignee: Marshall Schor
> Fix For: 2.3.1
>
>
> Write more test cases examining behavior regarding type/subtype inheritance
> for both features and types in result specs, and language subsumption
> testing, using both containsType or containsFeature, with and without
> intersection.
> Issues found include:
> * Supertype with allFeatures sets allFeatures for all subtypes. Correct
> behavior: specifying allFeatures on a type should only imply allFeatures for
> features that are known for that type. Features introduced only in subtypes
> should not be included.
> * -Serialization/deserialization ignores languages other than x-unspecified;
> it should support the full result-specification. potential (future?) use
> case: sending result specs to remote delegates.- This was due to a
> misinterpretation of a javadoc comment. The getResultTypesAndFeatures()
> (with no arguments) previously was defined to skip any language tests when
> retreiving the types and features. This is quite different from filtering
> only those with language x-unspecified. Make sure any rework keeps this
> behavior. That being said, the extracted types and features are missing any
> language information.
> * Assume a feature F introduced in a supertype T. A result spec T:F should
> be sufficient to return true for a test of T2:F, where T2 is a subtype ot T
> (currently returns false).
--
This message is automatically generated by JIRA.
-
You can reply to this email to add a comment to the issue online.
