Hi Justin, Regarding the roster on whimsy, I'm updating it right now.
The proposed PMC members come from the current identified PPMC. In Unomi, committers are also PPMC members. The main issue is that the initial committers forgot to sign the ICLA. I agree with you that we should cleanup the PMC set to actually consider only active PPMC. According to github (https://github.com/apache/incubator-unomi/graphs/contributors), it's not so far from the proposed PMC members proposed. Especially Sergiy, Kevan, Cédric, Régis, Quentin and David have contributed on the project. We sent a global e-mail to ask people to speak up if they want to continue as PMC members or not. Only a couple of guys sent feedback. I would go with a new cleanup. Right now, for sure, Serge, Thomas, François and myself clearly said we want to be PMC. @for all others, please, provide update if you want to be PMC member. I will discuss with Serge tomorrow to update the resolution proposal. Regards JB On 14/10/2018 03:09, Justin Mclean wrote: > Hi, > > I have a couple of concerns that hopefully you can address. > > First off your podling doesn’t seem to have any PPMC or committers on the > roster. [1] I not sure how you even able to commit code but perhaps something > is broken on the reporting side? > > The following people (from a quick search so I could be mistaken) don’t seem > to be active in your project, is there any reason they are being added to the > PPMC? Often at graduation it's best to ask inactive PPMC members if they want > to continue with the project. > > * Sergiy Shyrkov > * Kevan Jahanshahi > * Cédric Mailleux > * Régis Mora > * Quentin Lamerand > * David Griffon > > This shows a couple of those people active mid 2015 but not after that. [2] > > Three members of the proposed PPMC hasn’t even signed ICLAs (AFAIKS) which > seems a bit unusual. > > * Kevan Jahanshahi > * Cédric Mailleux > * Régis Mora > > And two others have only just signed them. Why are they signing them just > before graduation? > > Thanks, > Justin > > 1. https://whimsy.apache.org/roster/ppmc/unomi > 2. https://github.com/apache/incubator-unomi/graphs/contributors >
