Hi Kennard,
Yes, you are right, I should not delete the htable entry before calling
the publ_notify function. I will fix this. Thanks for pointing out.
Regards,
--
Anca Vamanu
www.voice-system.ro
On 09/03/2010 02:37 AM, kennard_wh...@logitech.com wrote:
Hi,
While looking at another feature (see patch upload 3058434) I came
across a strange behavior and traced it down to a section of presence
code.
Given an subscription (via SUBSCRIBE) and an existing presentity (via
PUBLISH) for event "presence", opensips send different NOTIFY PIDFs
documents depending upon if the presentity is expired via timeout vs
an explicit PUBLISH with Expires=0 header. In the first case
(timeout), the NOTIFY PIDF is completely missing the original
presentity (and the body may be empty if no other tuples). In the
second case (unpublish), the NOTIFY PIDF has an edited copy of the
original presentity (with basic status set closed). This occurs when
the presentity hash tables are enabled and fallback2db is disabled.
I doubt this is a really a bug (the behavior when presentities go away
is not defined by the RFCs as far as I can tell). But I suspect this
is a change in behavior introduced by the hash table code. Since some
clients react very differently to no-body NOTIFY messages compared to
ones containing 'closed' status, this can (and did) lead to strange
system behavior.
The root cause of the different behavior is that during message
cleaning, the presentity is deleted from the hash tables before the
notification is generated. In more detail, the call sequence is:
publish.c msg_presentity_clean() calls
notify.c: publ_notify() calls
notify.c: get_p_notify_body() calls
notify_body.c: pres_agg_nbody()
The etag of the expiring presentity (or its body index) is passed down
the above call chain. The last function attempts to "edit" the
expiring presentity, setting the basic status to 'closed' prior to
sending out the NOTIFY.
But the stale presentity is deleted from the hash table before the
above call sequence, thus it never shows up in the list of
presentities queried by get_p_notify_body() and is not edited to
indicate closed.
Probably msg_presentity_clean() calling publ_notify() with the
expiring etag doesn't serve any purpose, at least with fallback2db
disabled, and is potentially misleading since it doesn't do what one
would expect.
Regards,
Kennard
_______________________________________________
Devel mailing list
Devel@lists.opensips.org
http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/devel
