CALL: default security implementation

[Gerard van Enk]

CALL FOR:

Choosing a default security implementation for the next major release of MMBase (1.6). There are 2 (3, but the 3rd one isn't going to be default, because it only simulates the old security) different security implementations, context and cloud security (for more information see links section below).
Context security was the default implementation in the previous major MMBase release. The securityproject has changed this default implementation because it was needed by the distroproject to get a war which can be installed without configuration that needs to be changed.
This was done without a vote, but becuase it changes the default behaviour of MMBase a vote was needed.
In the mean time some discussion about the two different implementation has accured in the devlist, so I'm not proposing the cloud security but I'd like to ask you which one of the two must be made default in the next release (and also in CVS-HEAD).

This is majority call, with a margin of 3 votes.

Please pay attention: two votes must be made: 1 for context security and 1 for cloud security.


LINKS:

Context security <http://design.mmbase.org/testing/common/lastbuild/mmdocs/security/context-security.html>

Cloud security <http://design.mmbase.org/testing/common/lastbuild/mmdocs/security/cloud-security.html>


START OF CALL: 2002-10-22 0:30

END OF CALL: 2002-10-25 0:30


Context security being default:

[_] +1 (YEA)

[_] +0 (ABSTAIN )

[_] -1 (NAY), because :

[_] VETO, because:

Cloud security being default:

[_] +1 (YEA)

[_] +0 (ABSTAIN )

[_] -1 (NAY), because :

[_] VETO, because:


Gerard