Hi! today I was packaging Qt3D (meaning the the submodule) for Debian
and noticed that some symbols where missing. We understood that Qt3D
(the submodule) was API/ABI stable, but Konstantin Tokarev pointed
out:

  https://abi-laboratory.pro/tracker/timeline/qt/ "NOTE: The libQt53D*
objects are introduced in the library
  since 5.5.0 but with no stable ABI guarantee, so analysis of these
objects was not performed."

But then Thiago pointed out:

<thiago> well, we need to start having it stable
<thiago> it's no longer in experimental state
<thiago> $ git config -f .gitmodules --get submodule.qt3d.status
<thiago> addon
<thiago> qt3d left preview status in 5.7
<thiago> if there are libs inside that aren't stable ABI, they should
be moved to a separate module

So bringing up the issue here.


-- 
Lisandro Damián Nicanor Pérez Meyer
http://perezmeyer.com.ar/
http://perezmeyer.blogspot.com/
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN13Qt3DAnimation14QChannelMapper10addMappingEPNS_15QChannelMappingE@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN13Qt3DAnimation14QChannelMapper13removeMappingEPNS_15QChannelMappingE@Qt_5 
5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras19QMetalRoughMaterial12setBaseColorERK6QColor@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# _ZN10Qt3DExtras19QMetalRoughMaterial12setMetalnessEf@Qt_5 
5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# _ZN10Qt3DExtras19QMetalRoughMaterial12setRoughnessEf@Qt_5 
5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras19QMetalRoughMaterial16baseColorChangedERK6QColor@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras19QMetalRoughMaterial16metalnessChangedEf@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras19QMetalRoughMaterial16roughnessChangedEf@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# _ZN10Qt3DExtras22QOrbitCameraController12setLookSpeedEf@Qt_5 
5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras22QOrbitCameraController13cameraChangedEv@Qt_5 5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras22QOrbitCameraController14setLinearSpeedEf@Qt_5 5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras22QOrbitCameraController16lookSpeedChangedEv@Qt_5 5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras22QOrbitCameraController18linearSpeedChangedEv@Qt_5 
5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras22QOrbitCameraController9setCameraEPN10Qt3DRender7QCameraE@Qt_5 
5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial12setBaseColorEPN10Qt3DRender16QAbstractTextureE@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial12setMetalnessEPN10Qt3DRender16QAbstractTextureE@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial12setRoughnessEPN10Qt3DRender16QAbstractTextureE@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial13normalChangedEPN10Qt3DRender16QAbstractTextureE@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial16baseColorChangedEPN10Qt3DRender16QAbstractTextureE@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial16metalnessChangedEPN10Qt3DRender16QAbstractTextureE@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial16roughnessChangedEPN10Qt3DRender16QAbstractTextureE@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial19setAmbientOcclusionEPN10Qt3DRender16QAbstractTextureE@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial23ambientOcclusionChangedEPN10Qt3DRender16QAbstractTextureE@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial9setNormalEPN10Qt3DRender16QAbstractTextureE@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterialC1ERNS_34QTexturedMetalRoughMaterialPrivateEPN8Qt3DCore5QNodeE@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterialC2ERNS_34QTexturedMetalRoughMaterialPrivateEPN8Qt3DCore5QNodeE@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# _ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterialD0Ev@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# _ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterialD1Ev@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# _ZN10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterialD2Ev@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController12setLookSpeedEf@Qt_5 
5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController13cameraChangedEv@Qt_5 
5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController14setLinearSpeedEf@Qt_5 
5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController15setAccelerationEf@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController15setDecelerationEf@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController16lookSpeedChangedEv@Qt_5 
5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController18linearSpeedChangedEv@Qt_5 
5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController19accelerationChangedEf@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController19decelerationChangedEf@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController9setCameraEPN10Qt3DRender7QCameraE@Qt_5
 5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# _ZNK10Qt3DExtras22QOrbitCameraController11linearSpeedEv@Qt_5 
5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# _ZNK10Qt3DExtras22QOrbitCameraController6cameraEv@Qt_5 
5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# _ZNK10Qt3DExtras22QOrbitCameraController9lookSpeedEv@Qt_5 
5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZNK10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial16ambientOcclusionEv@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# _ZNK10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial6normalEv@Qt_5 
5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZNK10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial9baseColorEv@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZNK10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial9metalnessEv@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZNK10Qt3DExtras27QTexturedMetalRoughMaterial9roughnessEv@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZNK10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController11linearSpeedEv@Qt_5 
5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZNK10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController12accelerationEv@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZNK10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController12decelerationEv@Qt_5 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# _ZNK10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController6cameraEv@Qt_5 
5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZNK10Qt3DExtras28QFirstPersonCameraController9lookSpeedEv@Qt_5 5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN13Qt3DAnimation9Animation5Quick20Quick3DChannelMapper12mappingCountEP16QQmlListPropertyINS_15QChannelMappingEE@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN13Qt3DAnimation9Animation5Quick20Quick3DChannelMapper13appendMappingEP16QQmlListPropertyINS_15QChannelMappingEEPS4_@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN13Qt3DAnimation9Animation5Quick20Quick3DChannelMapper13clearMappingsEP16QQmlListPropertyINS_15QChannelMappingEE@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN13Qt3DAnimation9Animation5Quick20Quick3DChannelMapper9mappingAtEP16QQmlListPropertyINS_15QChannelMappingEEi@Qt_5
 5.9.0
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DRender20QRenderAspectPrivate17renderSynchronousEv@Qt_5 5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DRender6Render8Renderer14clearDirtyBitsE6QFlagsINS0_16AbstractRenderer20BackendNodeDirtyFlagEE@Qt_5
 5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZN10Qt3DRender6Render8Renderer17createOrUpdateVAOEPNS0_13RenderCommandEPN8Qt3DCore7QHandleINS0_23OpenGLVertexArrayObjectELj16EEEPPS6_@Qt_5_PRIVATE_API
 5.9.2
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# _ZN10Qt3DRender6Render8Renderer8doRenderEv@Qt_5 
5.7.1~20161122
+#MISSING: 5.10.1# 
_ZNK10Qt3DRender6Render22UpdateLevelOfDetailJob19viewMatrixForCameraERKN8Qt3DCore7QNodeIdER10QMatrix4x4S7_@Qt_5
 5.9.0
_______________________________________________
Development mailing list
Development@qt-project.org
http://lists.qt-project.org/mailman/listinfo/development

Reply via email to