Hi again, See below
> On 9 Jun 2017, at 17:56, Vincent Massol <[email protected]> wrote: > > Hi devs, > > Almost all our filters on jira.xwiki.org were wrong (all bugs for xwiki > committers, all issues for xwiki committers, etc) because they were only > filtering on the “top level” category (id = 10000) and thus were forgetting > the contrib extensions that we bundled in XE. > > Thus I’ve renamed the "top level projects” category into “XWiki Enterprise” > (and soon we’ll rename it with the name of the flavor replacing it). I’ve > also moved the conrib extensions that we bundled into that category. See > https://jira.xwiki.org/secure/Dashboard.jspa?selectPageId=10000 > > As a consequence this fixed > https://jira.xwiki.org/secure/Dashboard.jspa?selectPageId=10352 for example, > which is now correct. > > However this leads to a problem: All JQL we wrote that were using things like > “category in (“Top Level Projects”)” instead of “category = 10000” are now > broken. For example we use this in our Relaese Notes for bug fix releases. > I’ve fixed all of them using the Release Application but not old ones yet. > > Also, in our RN for bug fix releases we need to specify all projects one by > one along with versions. Writing the following (as can be seen in > http://www.xwiki.org/xwiki/bin/edit/ReleaseNotes/Data/XWiki/9.3.1/WebHome?editor=wiki) > is wrong for example: > > category = 10000 AND fixVersion in ("9.3.1") AND resolution in (Fixed) and > component not in ("Development Issues only”) > > FTR in the RN for 8.4.2 I wrote: > > category = 10000 and fixVersion = "8.4.2" and resolution = Fixed and > component != "Development Issues only" OR project = "CKEditor Integration" > and fixVersion = "1.10" and resolution = Fixed OR project = "Tour > Application" and fixVersion = "1.1" and resolution = Fixed > > But even that is not correct anymore and we now need to write instead: > > project IN ("XCOMMONS", "XRENDERING", "XWIKI", "XE") AND fixVersion = "8.4.2" > AND resolution = Fixed and component != "Development Issues only" OR project > = "CKEDITOR" AND fixVersion = "1.10" AND resolution = Fixed OR project = > "TOUR" AND fixVersion = "1.1" AND resolution = Fixed > > So we need to review: > * The filters and dashboard in jira.xwiki.org and fix them (for example GD, > in the RN for 9.4 we point to > https://jira.xwiki.org/secure/Dashboard.jspa?selectPageId=13894 which is > broken now since its filter uses “Top Level Projects” but I can’t fix it > since I don’t own it in jira…) > * The JQL statements used in xwiki.org and especially in the RNs. We should > probably create some scripts/tools to help us write those JQL. > > Any comment? Any other idea? Actually I have a better idea: * We should use the RN Application for all our releases and thus including the extensions bundled in XE too (Tour, Templates, Help Center, CK) * We should introduce the notion of Release Dependencies in the RN Application (see https://jira.xwiki.org/browse/RN-33) * Find ways to use the {{releasenotechanges/}} macro even for bugfix releases. Maybe by introducing a different type of “Change” which would contain the jira list (and we would add a new “Other” in addition to “user”, “admins” and “devs” for a change target). WDYT? Thanks -Vincent > Thanks > -Vincent >
