On Fri, Sep 7, 2018 at 2:37 PM Vincent Massol <[email protected]> wrote: > > Hi devs, > > Regarding Recommended extensions on e.x.o. > > What we don’t FTM is strategy for: > * A) When do we review the list of recommended and move some out when they’re > no longer matching the recommended criteria > * B) When do we review the list of not recommended and propose to move some > to recommended > > I guess for A) it could be when someone (community, committers) discovers > some important problems on the extension or if committers just notice it by > chance. In the future we could imagine having a “Unrecommend” button in the > UI to allow users to provide feedback as to why an extension should be > unrecommended. > > For B) it could the extension author proposing an extension to be recommended > (or committers noticing a good supported extension and asking the author(s) > if they’re willing to comply with the recommended rules). In the future we > could imagine having a “Recommend” button in the UI to allow users to provide > feedback as to why an extension should be recommended. > > WDYT? Any better or others ideas? > > Thanks > -Vincent >
A) I think someone who think an extension should not be recommended anymore should send a vote mail with the reasons. B) -1 for the “Recommend” button. The most important criteria for recommended extensions is to have an active maintainer and that maintainer should be active enough to send a vote on the dev mailing list to ask for the extension to become recommended IMO. -- Thomas Mortagne
