On Monday, 12 February 2024 at 18:22:46 UTC, H. S. Teoh wrote:
Honestly, I think this issue is blown completely out of proportion.
Only for people that don't have to deal with the problems it causes.
D decided on an unsigned type. You just learn that and adapt your code accordingly, end of story. Issues like these can always be argued both ways, and the amount of energy spent in these debates far outweigh the trivial workarounds in code, of which there are many (use std.conv.to for bounds checks, just outright cast it if you know what you're doing (or just foolhardy), use CheckedInt, etc.).
A terrible language is one that makes you expend your energy thinking about workarounds rather than solving your problems. The default should be code that works. The workarounds should be for cases where you want to do something extremely unusual like subtracting from an unsigned type and having it wrap around.
