Stewart Gordon wrote:
The plan to remove the built-in complex and imaginary types has finally come to my attention. I seem to have somehow blinked and missed the discussions earlier this year about it.

The motives seem to be along the lines of reducing compiler complexity (not sure if any pun has been intended) and freeing up keywords. But is it really worth it?

The argument for built-in imaginary types is _extremely_ weak. The imaginary numbers are not closed under multiplication:

idouble a, b;
auto c = a * b;

c is of type double! This is a horribly nasty thing to have in the core language. It introduces so many special cases, and for almost no benefit at all. You never want to use imaginary numbers, you _always_ want to convert them to reals. The only thing you want, really, is the imaginary literal 1i. The ireal, idouble, and ifloat types with their bizarre semantics are a hell of a price to pay for that one literal.

Reply via email to