"Joel C. Salomon" <[email protected]> wrote in message news:[email protected]... > Walter Bright wrote: >> I've used compilers that required explicit initializers for all >> variables. Sounds great in theory, in practice it *causes* bugs. >> >> What happens is the compiler dings the user with "initializer required." >> The user wants to get on with things, so he just throws in an >> initializer, any initializer, to get the compiler to shut up. > > Then the compiler is giving the wrong warning; it ought only to warn > that the variable is used before it has been set. >
Agreed. But let me pre-emptively address the inevitable "That would require flow analysis" that is scheduled for this point in the discussion: I've been thinking more and more that flow analysis is something that really needs to just get done for D at some point (I sympathetically realize that there are plenty of other things D also needs addressed). I'm no expert at this, but from prior discussions it sounds like this is something that's fairly well-understood. That together with the fact that the lack of it seems to be becoming more and more a stumbling block for various "very good things" leads me to beleive this is something that needs to just get done for D.
