On Tue, 05 May 2009 21:43:54 -0400, Ary Borenszweig <[email protected]> wrote:

Frank Benoit escribió:
In Java one can write:
 new MyClass().run();
 in D this does not compile, parenthesis are needed.
 (new MyClass()).run();
 But why is the D language designed like that?

I think it's because the (already hated by many, including myself) ability to invoke a function (or a constructor) without parenthesis.

So:
   new MyClass.run
and
   new MyClass().run

should be the same, right?

But in the first case MyClass could be a package name and you are constructing a new "MyClass.run" instance. You could make them behave differently, but some would say it's not consistent, etc.

If properties are every properly established, I hope the ability to call default constructors without having parens does not go away. It's different than a property function call.

I would say it's ok to make them behave differently. As others have said, we already have instances where you have to use parens to delineate where you are calling a function versus accessing a member.

For example, the (admittedly seldom used) chaining call of Stdout in Tango, if you want to insert a new line it's:

Stdout("hi")(4).newline()("hi");

Without the extra parens, it looks like you're trying to call newline with the argument "hi".

-Steve

Reply via email to