On Thu, 04 Jun 2009 10:00:27 +0400, Don <[email protected]> wrote:
bearophile wrote:
Denis Koroskin:
Shouldn't bitwise operations be disallowed on signed types at all?
It sounds OK to me, do Don & Walter agree?
Hmm. If you are doing bitwise operations, you are treating the number as
unsigned, no doubt about it. Some observations:
* The use of -1 for "all bits set" is in widespread use and is important.
ushort x ^= -1;
uint y ^= -1;
ulong z ^= -1;
probably needs to remain valid.
But then consider
(x ^ -1) + y
What is the type of x^-1 ? Is it ushort? Or int?
I see no problem adding implicit cast to unsigned counterparts here.
In this case size of (x ^ cast(uT)-1) would be unambiguous.
* A lot of existing C code uses bitwise operations on ints.
That's fine, raising an error in such cases is a good behavior.
* size_t had better be unsigned!