On 09/09/13 21:30, Jonathan M Davis wrote:
Walter's proposal would be no different on that count. All that the DIP is
proposing is a way to define a member function outside of a class. That
requires that it already be declared in the class, but it doesn't make it so
that you can't define other functions directly in the class.

Sure. The thing is that if you can only declare and define within the class, this potential problem is unavoidable -- you can _never_ be certain that your list of declarations is complete.

If on the other hand you can define outside the class declaration, then you can make it a design decision to only declare within the class declaration, and to define elsewhere in the module. In that case it should be possible to guarantee a safety check that what's declared is defined and what's defined is declared -- and that the two match precisely.

Reply via email to