On Thursday, 31 July 2014 at 08:23:44 UTC, Daniel Murphy wrote:
"Daniel Murphy" wrote in message news:[email protected]...

> Wait, what? I thought the whole point of enforce is that it > will *not*
> be removed by the compiler, no matter what?

No, the compiler is free to remove it if it can prove it will never be triggered. eg if the condition is checking a ubyte < 1000. If the assert in that example is never false, then the enforce is dead code.

Actually, thinking about this some more...

In this program the enforce can be removed

assert(x < y);
enforce(x < y);

But not in this one:

enforce(x < y);
assert(x < y);

because the compiler does need to take control flow into account when applying the information in the assert. In this case the assert does not actually give the compiler any new information.

No, if assert means "I promise that x < y where assert() is called", then "x < y" also holds when "enforce()" is called, because x and y cannot have changed between the two calls.

Reply via email to