Adam D. Ruppe wrote:
On Sat, Jan 23, 2010 at 12:00:04PM -0500, Steve Teale wrote:
I see that Go has now usurped D's former place at #13 in Tiobe - which I 
realize of course does not mean anything. But I'd be interested to hear what 
the D aficionados think of Go.

There's been a couple threads about it before. My opinion: it is garbage.
It has maybe two or three good ideas in there, but on the whole, it is
a very poor showing. The arrogant developers didn't do any research into
prior art when designing it, and it shows - good ideas are absent without
even a mention. Bad ideas remain in there saying "this is the best we could
do".

Oh well, D isn't that great either. While it doesn't have such big names attached on it (although "Andrei" is not that small of a name), it had more time.

What worries one most is how D rushes "to completion", just because of the deadline of that one book. It's obvious that some features are half cooked at best. Just look at the features added in D 2.038 (auto ref, DIP2): terrible hacks to get some broken language features barely to work before the deadline is over.

Also notice how the compiler, after all these years, still chokes up on basic language features. The struggling of the QtD developers is a major sign for this. I wonder what the heck is wrong with dmd's internal design that the situation is that bad. I mean, Walter could get a freaking C++ compiler right, why not the compiler for his own language?

/rant

The only reason it gets any attention at all is because of the names attached
to it.

Reply via email to