Michel Fortin wrote:
On 2010-02-10 22:54:40 -0500, Ary Borenszweig <[email protected]> said:

Ary Borenszweig wrote:
Michel Fortin wrote:
unittest {
    NonNullable!Object o;

Here o is null.

Sorry, just read the class comments. But if this can't be implemented without compiler support... then it's not of much use. :-(

To recapitulate the documentation comment at the top of NonNullable: it is indeed null until the first assignment. It's non nullable in the sense that you can't make it null, but it still can be null if you assign nothing to it. It means that if you encounter a null value in a non-nullable you know it was never initialized. So the obvious place to look is where it should have been initialized. I really wonder how bad this would be in practice (I haven't used it much yet).

That makes sense. :)

Unfortunately, there isn't a better way to implement NonNullable at the moment. An option could be to throw immediately at construction, but constructors with no arguments are not available for structs, and I'm not sure it'd be so great anyway.

Maybe in D2 you will be able to put @disable to the default constructor of the struct, so you'll have to explicity assign something to it.

There is also the issue of lack of polymorphism: a NonNullable!MyObject variable won't implicitly convert to NonNullable!Object, although I've been able to make it work for non-construction assignments using a template opAssign.

So I agree with you that it's of limited utility. I think it can still be useful at times. What would be great is non-nullable by default, but that's another thing entirely.

Yes, I think non-nullable by default is better.

Reply via email to