Andrei Alexandrescu wrote:
Norbert Nemec wrote:
Multidimensional arrays are the essence of the interfaces of most numerical libraries. Having several incompatible standards is a major roadblock for acceptance in the numerical community.

I'm not so sure about that. I was very enthusiastic about defining an infrastructure of arbitary-dimensional arrays, and did a little research about it. It turns out the applicability of N-dimensional arrays falls off a cliff when N > 3. In turn, this is because high-dimensional space are weird - an N-dimensional space is not just like a 3-dimensional one, only with more dimensions; it's a downright weird beast.

N-dimensional arrays are not tied to N-dimensional spaces.

If you view an array as data on a space-grid, then I agree that high dimensionality is awkward. I did work in high-energy physics, where four-dimensional space-time grids are commonly used for calculations. With the cost scaling in the fourth power of the resolution, this is extremely costly. Grid methods for N>4 are indeed rarely used.

Array dimensions, however, do not need to refer to space dimension. I, for example, often handle electron spins as additional indices of range two. Or number of particles in the system, and index for the various configurations of the system that need to be handled. There are unlimited possibilities what an index may mean.

Fortran 90 limits the number of dimensions to seven and in our current code, we actually were hit by this limit once when adding another dimension would actually have been the cleanest solution.

Of course, these are rare cases and probably indicate a questionable design to begin with, but as scientific software grows, one often just wants to add a new feature in the simplest and cleanest way. Having unnecessary limitations can easily get in the way.

Reply via email to