retard wrote:
Tue, 18 May 2010 12:13:02 -0700, Walter Bright wrote:

%u wrote:
The DMC++ compiler you mentioned sounds interesting too. I'd like to
compare performance with that, the VC++ one, and the Intel compiler.
When comparing D performance with C++, it is best to compare compilers
with the same back end, i.e.:

    dmd with dmc
    gcc with gdc
    lcc with ldc

This is because back ends can vary greatly in the code generated.

What if I'm using a clean room implementation of D with a custom backend and no accompanying C compiler, am I not allowed to compare the performance with anything?

You're allowed to do whatever you want. I'm pointing out that the difference in code generator ability should not be misconstrued as a difference in the languages.


When people compare C compilers, they usually use the latest Visual Studio, gcc, icc, and llvm versions -- i.e. C compilers from various vendors. Using the same logic one is not allowed to compare dmc against those since it would always lose.

It's perfectly reasonable to compare dmc and gcc for code generation quality.

Reply via email to