Sat, 06 Nov 2010 21:52:22 +0100, Jérôme M. Berger wrote: > FeepingCreature wrote: >> Walter Bright Wrote: >>> All that does is reinvent the null pointer seg fault. The hardware >>> does this for you for free. >> >> Walter, I know you're a Windows programmer but this cannot be the first >> time somebody has told you this - YOU CANNOT RECOVER FROM SEG FAULTS >> UNDER LINUX. >> >> Access violations are not a cross-platform substitute for exceptions. > > I really, really hope that you can't recover from seg faults on > Windows (or MacOS for that matter). Segmentation faults should be non > recoverable: once the program has started accessing memory that it > shouldn't, there is no way to guarantee that the program is in a > coherent state. Walter has stated this several times and I agree with > him 100% on this.
I also agree with him 100% on this. The problem non-nullable types try to solve is they reduce the number of possible segfaults in the first place. I don't care how hard the program crashes. I just don't want my client to experience that ever. Segfaults are terribly common in C/C++ code. I experience those every week. My initial motivation to study/use D was born from these crashes. I can't believe you're not using every possible known mechanism to prevent them.
