On 26/11/2010 19:50, Bruno Medeiros wrote:
Well, saying _dynamic arrays_ are a hybrid, like you mentioned, is
perhaps the best way to describe them, with less misunderstanding.

However, if I had to say whether dynamic arrays are value types or
reference types, I would agree with Jesse and call them reference types,
and I would not feel this is inaccurate.

ARRGHH, actually this is not entirely true, I forgot about something: null vs. empty arrays. Indeed on assignment (and parameter passing) dynamic arrays work just like reference types. The reallocation operations also don't go against that either. However, in D's dynamic arrays, null is the same as an empty array! Which in practice means there is no proper null "value" for dynamic arrays, like there is for other reference types, and I think that is kinda of an essential characteristic for a reference type. So actually I would not call D's dynamic arrays "reference types" and feel this is really accurate.

--
Bruno Medeiros - Software Engineer

Reply via email to