On 26/11/2010 16:56, Andrei Alexandrescu wrote:
On 11/26/10 9:30 AM, Bruno Medeiros wrote:
On 03/11/2010 20:33, Andrei Alexandrescu wrote:
On 11/3/10 7:07 AM, zhang wrote:
This code belown can be compiled with DMD 2.050. However, it throws an
error message:
core.exception.HiddenFuncError: Hidden method called for main.AClass

I'm not sure about whether it is a bug. Thanks for any help.
[snip]

That hidden functions are signaled during run time and not compile time
is a misunderstanding between design and implementation. There should
not be a HiddenFunc exception and the compiler should just refuse to
compile the program.


Andrei


Indeed! Is this part of the spec, or has Walter not agreed to it?

I think he was worried about the compiler becoming too restrictive.

Andrei

Well... I don't even know how to argue against that. I mean, when would a programmer ever prefer a runtime error instead of a compile-time one in this scenario? It's akin to saying the override keyword should never create a compile-time error, but instead throw a runtime one if the override-marked method doesn't actually override a super method.

(note: I know it's not your reasoning, but Walter's)

--
Bruno Medeiros - Software Engineer

Reply via email to