Andrei:

> Mentioning these to the outside blows the issues out of 
> proportion and conveys the wrong message to someone coming anew to D.

This is often true, unfortunately. But doing the opposite too has risks. If you 
keep saying only good things about a very complex systems X, people naturally 
start getting suspicious, because simply a so much complex system can't be 
perfect.

Such threads are always very messy. They are full of errors, good ideas, and 
everything else. I hope people do not believe everything said in such threads, 
both bad and good things. It's like a room full of people shouting, where half 
of them don't know what they are talking about :-)


> Plus, C++'s type system is marred by issues,

This is good information to know, thank you. I think most people need to write 
non obvious programs (like library code) both in C++ and D to understand some 
of the C++ problems you list, otherwise I think lot of programmers have 
difficulties understanding them in abstract, and they think D doesn't improve 
the situation enough compared to C++0x. D contains many improvements that are 
not easy to see. More articles that show D usage (compared to C++ too) are 
probably going to improve this a bit.

Bye,
bearophile

Reply via email to