On Mon, 17 Oct 2011 11:00:13 -0400, Steve Teale <[email protected]> wrote:

A direct translation is a derivative work.  So yes, it must be GPL.

However, there must be ways around this.  I believe headers have certain
rules in most licenses.

Steve, do you think this provides any relief>

http://www.mysql.com/about/legal/licensing/foss-exception/

I know our messages crossed paths probably, but for completeness, no, I don't think this allows relief. Boost is not listed as an allowed exception.

But this doesn't matter anyways. The *end product*, not phobos, must be licensed free and open source under the boost license. This is an important distinction.

This means, effectively, even if boost was included on the list, and we put mysql client bindings in phobos, in order to ship with mysql client library the user of phobos would have to license *their* product under boost! Even if they didn't ship the source for their application, anyone who obtained the application source through any means would be free to copy it at will. This limitation is too severe for inclusion in the core library of a language such as D, which might be used in closed-source settings.

Note that php and python are somewhat open-source anyways since they are interpreted, and commonly you do not need to distribute the source of your server-side code for it to be used.

-Steve

Reply via email to