Am 17.10.2011, 19:35 Uhr, schrieb Steven Schveighoffer
<[email protected]>:
On Mon, 17 Oct 2011 13:21:39 -0400, Norbert Nemec
<[email protected]> wrote:
On 17.10.2011 14:54, Steven Schveighoffer wrote:
Your best bet is to close the application, and possibly print a stack
trace. Trying to continue is like continuing to drive when you get a
flat tire. You are just going to keep damaging your car!
To stick with this nice analogy:
Trying to recover fully from a segfault is indeed like continuing to
ride with a flat tire. Bad idea!
Accepting the system default segfault handling is like abandoning the
whole valuable truckload just because of a flat tire. Not such a good
idea either.
Oh, well, that's up to the application design. I once designed a system
backed by a database that could be restarted and using the data in the
database could pick up exactly where it left off. You could call this
the AAA of application recovery :)
In many cases, the "valuable truckload" of an application is quickly and
easily recreated.
Sure, an emergency save may fail because of the memory corruption, but
there is a very good chance that it still works because the essential
data structures happen to be unaffected.
Or there's a chance it saves corrupted data, and screws your entire
database, or whatever. It all depends on the situation. Is it
recommended not to catch segfaults? Definitely. Should you ever do
it? Maybe, but don't rely on the resulting data for mission critical
applications. The only reason I can see to continue is to try and debug
the issue, not to continue running the program. You're better off
designing your application to recover via restarting.
-Steve
If an application tends to crash (like a few versions of Delphi did), an
auto-save feature will help. If you lose between 1-10 minutes of work at a
maximum you can probably live with that. I don't think it is a shame if
the application crashes when it is heavily plugin based. You just need to
accept and consider that in the application design. OpenOffice has
auto-save, Eclipse can restore previous installation states (i.e. before
installing a plugin) etc.