On 10/31/2011 02:49 AM, bearophile wrote:
Timon Gehr:
A lot of C's carefully designed syntactic elegance is
lost when going from pointers/iterators to arrays and ranges.
I think that a large part of that C syntactic elegance is an illusion. From my
experience, I want my code to look very simple to read and clean every time
this is possible. I want it to be easy to port to other languages, because I
have do it often enough. C code that uses lot of pointers is often bug-prone,
messy and hard to safely translate to other languages.
There are situation where pointers are necessary or are better than the
alternatives, or they give the needed flexibility, so I prefer a language with
pointers, but in a well designed language those situations are not common, and
I think raw pointers should be avoided when they are not needed. I have
debugged enough C code to be rather sure of this. Good luck with your pointers.
I rarely use pointers in D, its arrays are a better concept. I just
remarked that C code using pointers is sometimes more elegant than
equivalent D code using arrays or ranges, and that it is a little bit
unfortunate that we have all that while(*p && *p++ == --*q++){} stuff in
the D grammar without the possibility to use it.