On Wednesday, November 23, 2011 00:23:16 Timon Gehr wrote: > On 11/22/2011 11:00 PM, Manu wrote: > > So, I've been thinking about this const/lazy evaluation problem again. > > > > I think most of the complaints about D's const is due to the use of lazy > > evaluation for optimisation. I started wondering if there was room for a > > 'lazy' keyword. > > Perhaps if you declared some function as lazy, then the compiler would > > be expected to cache the return value, and also generate its own dirty > > flag, which it may manipulate in its own way. The compiler should have > > all the information it needs within the lazy function to know what > > external influences would cause a dirtying of the state. If they are > > sibling members as is often the case, it should be easy for them to be > > tagged to mark the dirt bit dirty whenever they are modified... if they > > are external non-const factors, then I would expect a warning (or > > error?). > > > > Just a thought anyway. Curious to know if anything like this has ever > > been considered... It might address the majority of the problems with > > D's const. > > Ie, I imagine a lazy function could also be marked const, and either, > > the compiler would have to just ignore the lazy cache and perform a full > > evaluation when called within a const context, OR it would be the > > responsibility of the compiler to implement the dirty logic in a 'safe' > > way (with respect to thread safety... lock free primitive usage? etc) > > > > Am I insane? > > > > - Manu > > I'd say variables would have to be declared as lazy, not functions. Then > you could set the dirty flag manually on mutable instances. Const > instances that refer to mutable data would benefit from lazy evaluation > while immutable instances would have to compute the lazy members during > their construction. This usage clashes with the current call by name > semantics of the lazy parameter storage class though.
This basic idea was discussed a couple of months back, and it was determined that it was overly complicated for very little gain. - Jonathan M Davis
