On Wed, 7 Dec 2011 20:56:17 +0100 Jens Mueller <[email protected]> wrote:
> Andrew Gough wrote: > > On Tue, 06 Dec 2011 18:14:25 +0000 > > Russel Winder <[email protected]> wrote: > > > > > SCons is a Python-based build tool to replace Make and much of the > > > Autotools functionality. It has D support as part of the core. > > > This support is though in need of development. > > > > > > The new Mercurial/BitBucket infrastructure for developing SCons > > > (replacing the old Subversion/Tigris set up) is now in place, a > > > new release 2.1.0 has been declared and everything is open for > > > business leading to a 2.2.0 release. > > > > > > I got my changes to support DMD 2 into this release :-) > > > > > > However, support for GDC, LDC, etc. is almost certainly still > > > sadly lacking, and indeed the support for DMD almost certainly > > > needs a severe refactoring and most likely a rewrite. > > > > > > Rather than people having to work on a clone of SCons in order to > > > work on the tool, I have created a separate Mercurial repository > > > (https://bitbucket.org/russel/scons_dmd_new) as a development > > > version of just the tool. When a new version of this separate > > > tool is declared I create a pull request for the SCons mainline > > > to get the new version in the next version of SCons. > > > > > > Is anyone else other than me interested in using SCons as a build > > > tool with D code? If there is, perhaps we can collaborate in > > > some way to progress SCons support for all the various > > > realizations of D? > > > > > > > I think the build tool question is in need of the same level of high > > level design and support that Steve Teale is working on for > > std.database/std.sql. > > > > It seems there is SCons support (python), CMake, Orbit (Ruby), DSSS > > (D1 only?), xfbuild, dake, rdmd options - I've added preliminary D > > support to premake. > > Where do I find your changes for premake? https://bitbucket.org/goughy/premake-dev-d > > > Would it be a good idea to thrash out the arguments for/against a > > particular tool, and build/support just one? The community doesn't > > seem big enough to be so fragmented. Java has Ant, Scala has sbt - > > surely D should have a canonical build tool? > > I'm unsure whether D needs its own configuration/build tool. It > definitely needs a package manager. > > For building there are different options but usually it's make. Most > people (at least for sure on Unix variants) are using it. I think > Scons does both building and configuring. Just want to say that you > can have different tools for these jobs or single one. > Jacob's build tool looks good but I wonder what are the major > improvements over e.g. make (portability is an issue with make; maybe > simplicity). > > For configuring there are some options and so far none of them is > preferred by a majority. Different people weigh different aspects > differently. But it seems people are moving away from configure > scripts. > > As Russell already said, several build/configuration tools are used > and there is no clear winner in general. So I think it's very nice > that you have added support for D to premake. So we then have SCons > (build and configuration), CMake (configuration and several build > tools via generators), rdmd (can generate dependencies for Makefile), > Jacob as a build tool and there are several others specifically for D > and premake. > > I'm not sure about the state of each of these. But SCons and CMake > work with dmd (both do configuration). premake is also configuration. > Regarding build tools I wonder how important they are. make works > fairly well. > > Jens The reasons I chose premake were primarily: 1. No external dependencies (lua embedded in an executable) 2. Simple configuration 3. Cross platform 4. Generates native build scripts: make, VS, Code::Blocks etc etc I have to point out that I have only added DMD+make support as that is all I needed at the time, but have plans (who doesn't :-D) to add support for LDC, GDC, and other build chains. -- Andrew Gough M: 0408 596 656 [email protected]
