On Thursday, 19 April 2012 at 07:26:44 UTC, Gleb wrote:
Jonas, thanks for your answer.
On Tuesday, 17 April 2012 at 20:03:57 UTC, Jonas Drewsen wrote:
This is one of the many reasons I believe we should do our own
network library. Curl only support timeouts for connecting and
for the entire transfer. What you really want is better control
with sane defaults: DNS lookup timeout, connect timeout,
read/write activity timeout and timout for the entire
operation.
Default "entire operation" timeout should be infinity and the
rest just some qualified guesses.
Anyway... I think the current default timeouts are how they
should be.
There are DNS timeout and connect timeout in current
std.net.curl. The entire operation timeout is infinity means
there is no such timeout - this is what curl library offers.
There is also some kind of read/write activity "timeout" in the
library because the connection will be dropped if ftp-server
shutdowns suddenly during uploading. That's why I don't see why
we have to have the data connection timeout which does not
allow the big files to be downloaded or uploaded.
Sorry for the delayed answer.
If the ftp server shuts down the tcp connection is broken and you
will get notified immediately. This has nothing to do with
timeouts (except maybe tcp timeouts in some cases which are
normally handled by the OS).
Most other libraries have a default timeout afaik and that makes
sense to me. As stated in my last reply the real solution would
to have an activity timeout which would make it reasonable to set
an infinite timeout for the entire transfer.
Regarding the 10 week limit you're mentioning please see the
docs
for the Duration type:
http://dlang.org/phobos/core_time.html#Duration
Thank's for the link! I've read it twice but unfortunately the
reason of 10 weeks limit is still not clear for me. Moreover I
can't understand why would dataTimeout influences
connectTimeout in such way if the value I use is more then 10
weeks.
I've not read the code for Duration but my guess is that it wraps
around and becomes a negative duration if you exceed the limit.
This would of course make it timeout immediately.
What you're describing sounds like a bug and I'll have a look
at
it.
Thank you very much! Your contribution to D's curl library
support is outstanding.
Just trying to make D a better place to be as so many others do :)
/Jonas
