On Wednesday, July 11, 2012 09:28:15 Benjamin Thaut wrote: > Am 10.07.2012 07:13, schrieb Jonathan M Davis: > > On Tuesday, July 10, 2012 06:53:29 Benjamin Thaut wrote: > >> Am 10.07.2012 00:53, schrieb Jonathan M Davis: > >>> On Monday, July 09, 2012 22:41:57 Benjamin Thaut wrote: > >>>> Clear uses the TypeInfo. The proposed functions should not be library > >>>> functions but directly aviable from the compiler. Something like > >>>> __postblit and __dtor but properly implemented. > >>> > >>> Well, since all of the necessary information is in the TypeInfo, not in > >>> the > >>> type itself, I don't see how you're going to do that. As I understand > >>> it, > >>> it's not the compiler that deals with all of that. It's druntime. So, > >>> without a major redesign, there's no way that the compiler is going to > >>> generate that stuff for you. That's druntime's job. > >>> > >>> - Jonathan M Davis > >> > >> So who fills the TypeInfo objects, the runtime? I always assumed that > >> the compiler fills the TypeInfo and therefor has all the neccessary > >> information already at hand. > > > > I don't know the details, but as I understand it, all of the logic for > > actually copying and destroying things properly is in druntime. The > > compiler doesn't do any of that. That being the case, any code which > > wants to use a type's postblit or destructor needs to use druntime. Right > > now, I believe that the compiler just uses hooks into the druntime code > > like it does with stuff like new and AAs. So, to skip using the druntime > > functions to properly copy or destroy an object, the compiler would have > > to duplicate the logic which currently resides in druntime. > > > > - Jonathan M Davis > > Thats fine, I don't want the compiler to duplicate that logic. I just > want the compiler to expose all the neccessary function that are > provided by the compiler anyway so *I* can duplicate the logic from > D-Runtime *without* going over a TypeInfo Object.
Then look over TypeInfo and see what it does. It may be possible to just duplicate what it's doing. I don't know. Certainly, TypeInfo is used by druntime to do the postblits and destructors, so even the compiler is using TypeInfo for doing that. - Jonathan M Davis
