discuss-archive  

Messages by Date

• 2026/01/11 Re: [PR] feat: Add ffi::Expected<T> for exception-free error handling [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 [PR] feat: Add ffi::Expected<T> for exception-free error handling [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 Re: [PR] [ADDONS] Update torch-c-dlpack-ext to 0.1.5 [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 Re: [PR] [ADDONS] Update torch-c-dlpack-ext to 0.1.5 [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 [PR] [ADDONS] Update torch-c-dlpack-ext to 0.1.5 [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 [GH] (tvm-ffi/error-abi): Workflow run "CI" is working again! GitBox
• 2026/01/11 Re: [PR] [CMAKE] Allow threads to be not found for cross compilation [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 [GH] (tvm-ffi/cmake-threads): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/11 Re: [PR] [CMAKE] Allow threads to be not found for cross compilation [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 Re: [PR] [CMAKE] Allow threads to be not found for cross compilation [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 [PR] [CMAKE] Allow threads to be not found for cross compilation [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 Re: [PR] [Relax] Move SymbolicMatcher to tir/analysis [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 Re: [PR] Put options before objects when compiling [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 Re: [PR] [Relax] Remove obsolete TODO comments [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 Re: [PR] Put options before objects when compiling [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 [PR] Put options before objects when compiling [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 Re: [I] [BUG] tvm::ffi::Any compilation failure with refl::init: missing TypeStr trait [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 Re: [I] [BUG] tvm::ffi::Any compilation failure with refl::init: missing TypeStr trait [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 Re: [I] [BUG] tvm::ffi::Any compilation failure with refl::init: missing TypeStr trait [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 Re: [PR] [Relax] Move SymbolicMatcher to tir/analysis [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/11 Re: [PR] [Relax] Remove obsolete TODO comments [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] doc: Function, Exception and Module [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 [I] [Bug] Segmentation fault when importing `torchmetrics` after creating a TVM CUDA target (LLVM initialization / COFF OptTable) [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] doc: Function, Exception and Module [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] doc: Function, Exception and Module [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] doc: Function, Exception and Module [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 [GH] (tvm-ffi/2026-01-09/doc-func): Workflow run "CI" is working again! GitBox
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] doc: Function, Exception and Module [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 [GH] (tvm/main): Workflow run "Nightly Docker Update" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] doc: Function and Module [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 [GH] (tvm-ffi/error-abi): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/10 [GH] (tvm-ffi/error-abi): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/10 [GH] (tvm-ffi/error-abi): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] [RFC][Error][ABI] Update Error to enable future compact to cause chaining [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] [Error][ABI] Update Error to enable future compact to cause chaining [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] [Error][ABI] Update Error to enable future compact to cause chaining [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 [PR] [Error][ABI] Update Error to enable future compact to cause chaining [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] doc: Function and Module [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] feat: Add `tvm_ffi.Function.__init__` [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] [FFI] bump to latest version [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] [FFI] bump to latest version [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 [PR] [FFI] bump to latest version [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] doc: Function and Module [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 [GH] (tvm/main): Workflow run "Teams" is working again! GitBox
• 2026/01/10 [I] [Bug] Segmentation fault when using TVM together with `transformers` (flan-t5-base + bfloat16 + `use_cache=True`) [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 [GH] (tvm/fix-typo-indice-to-index): Workflow run "CI" is working again! GitBox
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] fix: TypeStr support for Any type in reflection Init [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] fix: TypeStr support for Any type in reflection Init [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] [Relax][ONNX] Add support for Unique optional outputs [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] [Relax][ONNX] Add support for Unique optional outputs [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 [PR] [Relax][ONNX] Add support for Unique optional outputs [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] feat: Add `tvm_ffi.Function.__init__` [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/10 Re: [PR] fix: TypeStr support for Any type in reflection Init [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 [I] [Bug] Segfault in LLVM COFFOptTable when combining TVM CUDA target with PyTorch Lightning + torchmetrics in the same process [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] feat: Add `tvm_ffi.Function.__init__` [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] feat: Add `tvm_ffi.Function.__init__` [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] feat: Add `tvm_ffi.Function.__init__` [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 [PR] feat: Add `tvm_ffi.Function.__init__` [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] fix: TypeStr support for Any type in reflection Init [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] doc: Function and Module [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] doc: Function and Module [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 [PR] doc: Function and Module [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 [GH] (tvm/main): Workflow run "Nightly Docker Update" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] [ADRENO][TEXTURE] Texture based lowering [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 [GH] (tvm/fix-typo-indice-to-index): Workflow run "CI" is working again! GitBox
• 2026/01/09 [GH] (tvm/move-symbolic-matcher-to-tir): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] [ADRENO][TEXTURE] Texture based lowering [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] [Relax] Move SymbolicMatcher to tir/analysis [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] [Relax] Move SymbolicMatcher to tir/analysis [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 [PR] [Relax] Move SymbolicMatcher to tir/analysis [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] [Relax] Remove obsolete TODO comments [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] [Relax] Remove obsolete TODO comments [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 [PR] Remove Obsolete TODO Comments [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 [GH] (tvm/main): Workflow run "tvm-bot" is working again! GitBox
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] [WIP][CI] Upgrade CI to Python 3.10 [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] feat: Restrict `__slots__=()` for subclasses of `tvm_ffi.Object` by default [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] docs: document structural_equal and structural_hash for Array and Map [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] doc: Object and Class [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 [GH] (tvm-ffi/fix/any-typestr-trait): Workflow run "CI" is working again! GitBox
• 2026/01/09 [GH] (tvm-ffi/fix/any-typestr-trait): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] fix: TypeStr support for Any type in reflection Init [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] fix: TypeStr support for Any type in reflection Init [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 [PR] fix: TypeStr support for Any type in reflection Init [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] docs: document structural_equal and structural_hash for Array and Map [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [I] [Bug] [FRONTEND][ONNX] Error converting operator ConvTranspose: InternalError: In Op(relax.add), the first input shape at dim 1 is T.int64(16) and the second input shape at dim 1 is T.int64(32), which are not broadcastable. [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 [GH] (tvm/update-python-3.10): Workflow run "CI" is working again! GitBox
• 2026/01/09 Re: [I] [Bug] [FRONTEND][ONNX] Error converting operator ConvTranspose: InternalError: In Op(relax.add), the first input shape at dim 1 is T.int64(16) and the second input shape at dim 1 is T.int64(32), which are not broadcastable. [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] doc: Object and Class [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] doc: Object and Class [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] doc: Object and Class [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 Re: [PR] doc: Object and Class [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 [GH] (tvm/update-python-3.10): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/09 [GH] (tvm/main): Workflow run "Teams" is working again! GitBox
• 2026/01/09 [I] [Bug] `relax.frontend.torch.from_exported_program` aborts on sparse CSR buffer (`layout_impl is only implemented for TensorImpl subclasses`) [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/09 [GH] (tvm/update-python-3.10): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/09 [GH] (tvm/update-python-3.10): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/08 [GH] (tvm/update-python-3.10): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] feat: add starts_with and ends_with to String [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 [GH] (tvm/update-python-3.10): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] feat: add starts_with and ends_with to String [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 [GH] (tvm/update-python-3.10): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] ci: add clang-tidy to ci_test [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [I] [VOTE] Release Apache TVM FFI v0.1.8-rc0 [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 [GH] (tvm/update-python-3.10): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/08 Re: [I] [VOTE] Release Apache TVM FFI v0.1.8-rc0 [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 [GH] (tvm/update-python-3.10): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] [WIP][CI] Upgrade CI to Python 3.10 [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 [GH] (tvm/update-python-3.10): Workflow run "PR" is working again! GitBox
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] [WIP][CI] Upgrade CI to Python 3.10 [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 [PR] [WIP][CI] Upgrade CI to Python 3.10 [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [I] [VOTE] Release Apache TVM FFI v0.1.8-rc0 [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [I] [VOTE] Release Apache TVM FFI v0.1.8-rc0 [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 [GH] (tvm/main): Workflow run "Nightly Docker Update" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] doc: Object and Class [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 [PR] doc: Object and Class [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] doc: Object and Class [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [I] [VOTE] Release Apache TVM FFI v0.1.8-rc0 [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [I] [Feature Request] support torch 1.14/2.0.0 [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [I] [VOTE] Release Apache TVM FFI v0.1.8-rc0 [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [I] [VOTE] Release Apache TVM FFI v0.1.8-rc0 [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 [I] [VOTE] Release Apache TVM FFI v0.1.8-rc0 [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] ci: add clang-tidy to ci_test [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] fix: out-of-bounds read in `StringViewToDLDataType_` with non-null-terminated strings [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] fix: out-of-bounds read in `StringViewToDLDataType_` with non-null-terminated strings [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] fix: out-of-bounds read in `StringViewToDLDataType_` with non-null-terminated strings [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] fix: out-of-bounds read in `StringViewToDLDataType_` with non-null-terminated strings [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] doc: Tensor Usage [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] doc: Any and AnyView [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] [ADRENO][TEXTURE] Texture based lowering [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] [ADRENO][TEXTURE] Texture based lowering [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] [ADRENO][TEXTURE] Texture based lowering [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] [Compile] accelerate compilation speed using NVRTC [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] feat: add startswith and endswith to String [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] feat: add equality and hash support for Array and Map [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] doc: Tensor Usage [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] doc: Tensor Usage [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 [PR] doc: Tensor Usage [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] [feat] Add overflow check for uint64_t/size_t in TypeTraits<Int>::CopyToAnyView [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] fix: out-of-bounds read in `StringViewToDLDataType_` with non-null-terminated strings [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] ci: add clang-tidy to ci_test [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] doc: Add documentation for Any and AnyView [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] doc: Add documentation for Any and AnyView [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] [LLVM][Codegen] Cast NAN to bool gives true [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 Re: [PR] [LLVM][Codegen] Cast NAN to bool gives true [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/08 [PR] [LLVM][Codegen] Cast NAN to bool gives true [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] ci: add clang-tidy to ci_test [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] ci: add clang-tidy to ci_test [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] fix: out-of-bounds read in `StringViewToDLDataType_` with non-null-terminated strings [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] fix: out-of-bounds read in `StringViewToDLDataType_` with non-null-terminated strings [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] fix: out-of-bounds read in `StringViewToDLDataType_` with non-null-terminated strings [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] [IR][Transform] Implement SequentialNode::ResolveDependency() [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] [IR][Transform] Implement SequentialNode::ResolveDependency() [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 [PR] [IR][Transform] Implement SequentialNode::ResolveDependency() [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] feat: add startswith and endswith to String [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] ci: add clang-tidy to ci_test [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] ci: add clang-tidy to ci_test [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] fix: out-of-bounds read in `StringViewToDLDataType_` with non-null-terminated strings [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] feat: add startswith and endswith to String [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] ci: add clang-tidy to ci_test [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] feat: add startswith and endswith to String [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 [GH] (tvm/main): Workflow run "Nightly Docker Update" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] Bump urllib3 from 1.26.18 to 2.6.0 in /docker/python [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 [PR] Bump urllib3 from 1.26.18 to 2.6.3 in /docker/python [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] Bump urllib3 from 1.26.18 to 2.6.0 in /docker/python [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] [feat] Add overflow check for uint64_t/size_t in TypeTraits<Int>::CopyToAnyView [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] [feat] Add overflow check for uint64_t/size_t in TypeTraits<Int>::CopyToAnyView [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] [feat] Add overflow check for uint64_t/size_t in TypeTraits<Int>::CopyToAnyView [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] [feat] Add overflow check for uint64_t/size_t in TypeTraits<Int>::CopyToAnyView [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] [feat] Add overflow check for uint64_t/size_t in TypeTraits<Int>::CopyToAnyView [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] fix: out-of-bounds read in `StringViewToDLDataType_` with non-null-terminated strings [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] fix: out-of-bounds read in `StringViewToDLDataType_` with non-null-terminated strings [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] fix: out-of-bounds read in `StringViewToDLDataType_` with non-null-terminated strings [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] fix: out-of-bounds read in `StringViewToDLDataType_` with non-null-terminated strings [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] feat: add startswith and endswith to String [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 [GH] (tvm-ffi/fix/dtype-from-non-null-terminated-string): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] [Relax] Add FRelaxInferLayout for scatter_nd operator [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] [Relax] Add FRelaxInferLayout for gather_elements operator [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] improve typing for tir.PrimExpr [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] ci: add clang-tidy to ci_test [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] [Relax] Add FRelaxInferLayout for gather_elements operator [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] [Relax] Add FRelaxInferLayout for scatter_nd operator [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 Re: [PR] [Relax] Add FRelaxInferLayout for scatter_nd operator [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/07 [GH] (tvm-ffi/feat/add-clang-tidy-precommit): Workflow run "CI" is working again! GitBox
• 2026/01/07 [GH] (tvm-ffi/feat/add-clang-tidy-precommit): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/07 [GH] (tvm-ffi/feat/add-clang-tidy-precommit): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/07 [GH] (tvm-ffi/feat/add-clang-tidy-precommit): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/07 [GH] (tvm-ffi/feat/add-clang-tidy-precommit): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/06 Re: [PR] [Relax] Add FRelaxInferLayout for gather_elements operator [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/06 [GH] (tvm-ffi/feat/add-clang-tidy-precommit): Workflow run "CI" failed! GitBox
• 2026/01/06 Re: [PR] ci: add clang-tidy to pre-commit and CI lint job [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/06 [PR] ci: add clang-tidy to pre-commit and CI lint job [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/06 Re: [PR] ci: add clang-tidy to pre-commit and CI lint job [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/06 Re: [PR] feat: add startswith and endswith to String [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/06 Re: [PR] feat: add startswith and endswith to String [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/06 [PR] feat: add startswith and endswith to String [tvm-ffi] via GitHub
• 2026/01/06 Re: [PR] [Relax] Add FRelaxInferLayout for scatter_nd operator [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/06 [PR] [Relax] Add FRelaxInferLayout for scatter_nd operator [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/06 Re: [PR] [Relax] Add FRelaxInferLayout for scatter_nd operator [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/06 Re: [PR] [Relax] Add FRelaxInferLayout for gather_elements operator [tvm] via GitHub
• 2026/01/06 Re: [PR] [Relax] Add FRelaxInferLayout for gather_elements operator [tvm] via GitHub

• Earlier messages
• Later messages