Thanks. I'll look at both those points before reverting. :)
On Wed, Oct 14, 2020 at 7:18 PM Marcus Müller <muel...@kit.edu
<mailto:muel...@kit.edu>> wrote:
again,
1. outdated GNU Radio. More modern GNU Radio might perform
better.
Updating isn't really optional when you're musing about
performance.
2. actually benchmark where your CPU is going. `htop` is a
good tool if
you turn on "thread names" in its settings.
Best regards,
Marcus
On 14/10/2020 15.26, Anish Mangal wrote:
> Hi Marcus,
>
> Thanks for the quick reply. Here's a more complete flow
diagram that
> doesn't use the block I mentioned above.
>
> https://pasteboard.co/JvBTisO.png
>
> This uses up most of my CPU, so I was wondering whether it
was possible
> to spread this across multiple distinct computers. I'm
sorry, that I
> can't share my most up to date block diagram which uses
actual audio
> sources instead of coldplay songs, as it is on another
machine which I
> dont have access to at the moment, but this gives a fairly
good idea
> about the number of blocks and processing units.
>
> Thoughts?
>
>
>
> On Wed, Oct 14, 2020 at 6:48 PM Marcus Müller
<muel...@kit.edu <mailto:muel...@kit.edu>
> <mailto:muel...@kit.edu <mailto:muel...@kit.edu>>> wrote:
>
> Hi Anish,
>
> what your subject line says, distributing across CPUs,
GNU Radio does
> automatically.
>
> Across multiple distinct computers, you'll need to add
some signal
> communications between these computers. The ZeroMQ
network sinks and
> sources do that for you.
>
> But honestly, the flow graph you show should use nearly
no CPU at all.
> You should investigate what, in your overall flow
graph, not just in
> the
> excerpt you showed, uses up your CPU. This should
really not be a big
> task for your computer.
>
> Also, you're using an outdated version of GNU Radio.
Time to update!
>
> Best regards,
> Marcus
>
> On 14/10/2020 15.07, Anish Mangal wrote:
> > Hi, This is my very first post to this mailing list,
so hello to
> all. I
> > am a beginner in experimenting with gnuradio and sdr
> (hackrf-one). I am
> > working on an application where I want to take
multiple audio input
> > sources and transmit multiple FM signals over one RF
channel via the
> > SDR. To this end, I created a basic grc block that
looks like this:
> >
> > https://pasteboard.co/JvBGgj5.png
> >
> > My plan is to have a top level flow diagram using
multiple such
> blocks
> > and sum them to produce a composite FM signal
through the
> hackrf-one.
> > With my 4th generation intel i7 CPU, with the
hackrf's bandwidth
> set to
> > 6MSPS, I am able to transmit 6 simultaneous fm
modulated signals. My
> > question is this:
> >
> > Is it possible to spread this task across multiple
computers. If one
> > computer could produce the FM modulated signals, and
the other
> computer
> > sum them and transmit via the SDR, the number of
simultaneous
> streams
> > may be increased.
> >
> > Another approach might be to offload parts of this
block diagram
> to an
> > FPGA processing unit.
> >
> > My challenge is this. I have no experience of
working with an
> FPGA, and
> > limited experience with gnu-radio in general, but I
am prepared
> to put
> > in the effort required, however, if someone more
experienced than
> me can
> > guide me on the proper approach to go about this, it
would be very
> > helpful. It may be that I just keep all the
processing on ONE
> powerful
> > CPU, and whatever is the max number of simultaneous
streams I can
> get,
> > that's it. But if there are cost effective ways of
making this
> design
> > more efficient, I'm happy to research and experiment.
> >
> > 73,
> > VU2TVE // Anish
> >
>
