> Fair use's ambiguity definitely does have some benefits, but on industr=
y
> which doesn't like the ambiguity is insurance. I once had a conversatio=
n
> with the founder of Kartemquinn Films (Hoop Dreams, etc.) and he
> explained how documentarians have a lot of trouble getting insurance fo=
r
> their films because if they are sued, the film could never come out.=20
>=20
> This has been mitigated by "best practices" like the one for documentar=
y
> film makers put out by American University, but that does remove _some_=

> ambiguity from fair use.

In my opinion the only thing worse than ambiguity is no ambiguity,
because lack of ambiguity never errs on the side of Fair Use. ;-)

Over the decades, Fair Dealing in the UK has been reduced to little more
than the right to give a positive review for a work. Best practice
guidelines, if adopted as a requirement by insurers, may practically
limit the general scope of Fair Use.

It's a trade off, but as I say the real world experience of Fair Dealing
is that once you set an explicit limit it is only ever made more limited.=


- Rob.

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: OpenPGP digital signature

_______________________________________________
Discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://freeculture.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss

Reply via email to