> MPlayer is not part of the base OS, so it is not something to be  discussed


Obviously I was not "talking" seriously.

> in relation to a software consolidation for a base OS. Tar, pax and  similar 
> however are part of the base OS. See:
> 
>     http://www.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/9699919799/
> 
> for a list of utilities  that are part of the base OS.

Althouth pax is there, still I cannot find tar in 

http://www.opengroup.org/onlinepubs/9699919799/idx/utilities.html

> The reason why you believe to have problems with Sun tar is that  you get 
> archives that have been created by GNU tar amd that are not standard  
>compliant.

No I do not believe, I do have problems and that's why I have to use gtar.
The reason is obvious and clearly I cannot force everyone to create archives
that comply to the  standard.

> Since Sun tar is tested against the star test suite since  autumn 2004, it is 
> really POSIX compliant since then. If you really like to  replace tar by 
>GNUtar, 
>
> then you would repplace something that is standard  compliant with something 
> that is not and in turn create even more problems  with data exchange between 
> different Solaris distros.

Sun did a lot of great things but also many stupid things, so let's keep it out 
of the
discussion. I do not want to replace anything, I just want to be able to use 
GNUtar
and many other GNU utilities. On my machines I do use GNU things only as the
"standard" utilities cause many problems when trying to compile standard tools.

> BTW: star is  able to unpack more archives created by GNU tar than GNU tar ;-)
> Star on the  other side create POSIX compliant archives.

OK. I have star on my system. The question is why not include all three 
different
tar's?
 
> However, in case you believe  that I like to replace sun tar by star 
> immediately, the first step of  integrating star is intended to allow 
> everyone 


Personally I do not believe anything! I just want to see things move forward.
And this is the reason I started this thread. 

A.S.


----------------------
Apostolos Syropoulos
Xanthi, Greece


      
_______________________________________________
Discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.illumos.org/m/listinfo/discuss

Reply via email to