Hi
      replacing-1              ONLINE       0     0     0
c0t5000C500A71CEEFFd0  ONLINE       0     0     0   | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  44   c0t5000C500AE8296AFd0  ONLINE       0     0     0   | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  90


This is a mirror. You can remove one of the disks via zpool detach to solve the unwanted mirror situation and to free a disk. Then use zpool replace to replace the faulted disks with working ones.

The avail hotspare should have jumped in?

gea


On 16.11.2020 15:31, Schweiss, Chip wrote:
Posted to the wrong list.  Adding to illumos-discuss.

On Mon, Nov 16, 2020 at 8:22 AM Schweiss, Chip <[email protected] <mailto:[email protected]>> wrote:

    I have a distressed pool that I cannot get a faulted disk to replace.

    This is the pool as I discovered it this morning:

      pool: drpool04
     state: DEGRADED
    status: One or more devices is currently being resilvered.  The
    pool will
            continue to function, possibly in a degraded state.
    action: Wait for the resilver to complete.
      scan: resilver in progress since Sat Nov 14 11:35:02 2020
            140T scanned out of 388T at 952M/s, 76h6m to go
        3.20T resilvered, 35.96% done
    config:

            NAME                         STATE     READ WRITE CKSUM
            drpool04                     DEGRADED     0   0     0
              raidz2-0                   ONLINE       0   0     0
                c0t5000C500A7174C1Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   2
                c0t5000C500A7166DBBd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   3
                c0t5000C500A715FB3Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   4
                c0t5000C500A71BA81Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   5
                c0t5000C500A716D993d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   6
                c0t5000C500A717C8BFd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   7
                c0t5000C500A709DDFBd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   8
                c0t5000C500A71976E7d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   9
                c0t5000C500A716CB5Fd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  10
                c0t5000C500A7193247d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  11
                c0t5000C500A7196AF3d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  12
                c0t5000C500A716578Fd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  13
                c0t5000C500A7174387d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  14
                c0t5000C500A71CFB77d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  15
              raidz2-1                   ONLINE       0   0     0
                c0t5000C500A717F117d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  16
                c0t5000C500A7161D3Fd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  17
                c0t5000C500A687FDA7d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  18
                c0t5000C500A6865B7Fd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  19
                c0t5000C500A7192253d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  20
                c0t5000C500A719770Fd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  21
                c0t5000C500A714668Fd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  22
                c0t5000C500A71E23F7d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  23
                c0t5000C500A715EF3Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  24
                c0t5000C500A71BAE9Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  25
                c0t5000C500A717BD6Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  26
                c0t5000C500A71B91E7d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  27
                c0t5000C500A716881Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  28
                c0t5000C500A6865B17d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  29
              raidz2-2                   DEGRADED     0   0     0
                c0t5000C500A716FA4Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  30
                c0t5000C500A688424Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  31
                c0t5000C500A716DA2Fd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  32
                spare-3                  FAULTED      0   0     0
                  c0t5000C500A7192247d0  FAULTED      0   0     0
     external device fault
                  c0t5000C500A71CEEFFd0  ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  44
                c0t5000C500A71919F7d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  34
                c0t5000C500A717C6B7d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  35
                c0t5000C500A716CE77d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  36
                c0t5000C500A6CA7707d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  37
                c0t5000C500A71BB05Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  38
                spare-9                  UNAVAIL      0   0     0
     insufficient replicas
                  5305257770530967646    UNAVAIL      0   0     0  was
    /dev/dsk/c0t5000C500A6F8BDDFd0s0
                  1685164993699279407    FAULTED      0   0     0  was
    /dev/dsk/c0t5000C500A71CEEFFd0s0
                c0t5000C500A71DD4A7d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  40
                c0t5000C500A718431Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  41
                c0t5000C500A6866C13d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  42
                c0t5000C500A7148C97d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  43
            spares
              c0t5000C500A71CEEFFd0      INUSE currently in use     |
    MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  44
              c0t5000C500A716C0F3d0      AVAIL              |
    MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  45

    errors: No known data errors

    I then detached the unavail disk followed by a replace, which
    failed.  I then tried adding another spare to get the replace
    going.  It failed the same way, until I replaced it while not
    attached to the pool.  However, it attached to the wrong disk!



    # zpool detach drpool04 5305257770530967646
    # ozmt-zpool-status.sh drpool04
      pool: drpool04
     state: DEGRADED
    status: One or more devices is currently being resilvered.  The
    pool will
            continue to function, possibly in a degraded state.
    action: Wait for the resilver to complete.
      scan: resilver in progress since Sat Nov 14 11:35:02 2020
            142T scanned out of 388T at 961M/s, 74h36m to go
        3.26T resilvered, 36.63% done
    config:

            NAME                         STATE     READ WRITE CKSUM
            drpool04                     DEGRADED     0   0     0
              raidz2-0                   ONLINE       0   0     0
                c0t5000C500A7174C1Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   2
                c0t5000C500A7166DBBd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   3
                c0t5000C500A715FB3Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   4
                c0t5000C500A71BA81Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   5
                c0t5000C500A716D993d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   6
                c0t5000C500A717C8BFd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   7
                c0t5000C500A709DDFBd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   8
                c0t5000C500A71976E7d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   9
                c0t5000C500A716CB5Fd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  10
                c0t5000C500A7193247d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  11
                c0t5000C500A7196AF3d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  12
                c0t5000C500A716578Fd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  13
                c0t5000C500A7174387d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  14
                c0t5000C500A71CFB77d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  15
              raidz2-1                   ONLINE       0   0     0
                c0t5000C500A717F117d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  16
                c0t5000C500A7161D3Fd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  17
                c0t5000C500A687FDA7d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  18
                c0t5000C500A6865B7Fd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  19
                c0t5000C500A7192253d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  20
                c0t5000C500A719770Fd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  21
                c0t5000C500A714668Fd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  22
                c0t5000C500A71E23F7d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  23
                c0t5000C500A715EF3Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  24
                c0t5000C500A71BAE9Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  25
                c0t5000C500A717BD6Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  26
                c0t5000C500A71B91E7d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  27
                c0t5000C500A716881Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  28
                c0t5000C500A6865B17d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  29
              raidz2-2                   DEGRADED     0   0     0
                c0t5000C500A716FA4Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  30
                c0t5000C500A688424Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  31
                c0t5000C500A716DA2Fd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  32
                spare-3                  DEGRADED     0   0     0
                  c0t5000C500A7192247d0  FAULTED      0   0     0
     external device fault
                  c0t5000C500A71CEEFFd0  ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  44
                c0t5000C500A71919F7d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  34
                c0t5000C500A717C6B7d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  35
                c0t5000C500A716CE77d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  36
                c0t5000C500A6CA7707d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  37
                c0t5000C500A71BB05Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  38
                1685164993699279407      FAULTED      0   0     0  was
    /dev/dsk/c0t5000C500A71CEEFFd0s0
                c0t5000C500A71DD4A7d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  40
                c0t5000C500A718431Bd0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  41
                c0t5000C500A6866C13d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  42
                c0t5000C500A7148C97d0    ONLINE       0   0     0    
    | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  43
            spares
              c0t5000C500A716C0F3d0      AVAIL              |
    MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  45

    errors: No known data errors

    # zpool replace drpool04 1685164993699279407 c0t5000C500A716C0F3d0
    cannot replace 1685164993699279407 with c0t5000C500A716C0F3d0:
    already in replacing/spare config; wait for completion or use
    'zpool detach'

    # zpool attach drpool04 1685164993699279407 c0t5000C500A716C0F3d0
    cannot attach c0t5000C500A716C0F3d0 to 1685164993699279407:
    c0t5000C500A716C0F3d0 is busy, or device removal is in progress

    # zpool add drpool04 spare c0t5000C500AE8296AFd0
    # zpool replace drpool04 1685164993699279407 c0t5000C500AE8296AFd0
    cannot replace 1685164993699279407 with c0t5000C500AE8296AFd0:
    already in replacing/spare config; wait for completion or use
    'zpool detach'

    # zpool attach drpool04 1685164993699279407 c0t5000C500AE8296AFd0
    invalid vdev specification
    use '-f' to override the following errors:
    /dev/dsk/c0t5000C500AE8296AFd0s0 is reserved as a hot spare for
    ZFS pool drpool04.  Please see zpool(1M).

    # zpool remove drpool04 c0t5000C500AE8296AFd0

    *# zpool replace drpool04 1685164993699279407 c0t5000C500AE8296AFd0*

    Now it is attached to the wrong disk:

    # ozmt-zpool-status.sh drpool04
      pool: drpool04
     state: DEGRADED
    status: One or more devices is currently being resilvered.  The
    pool will
            continue to function, possibly in a degraded state.
    action: Wait for the resilver to complete.
      scan: resilver in progress since Mon Nov 16 07:55:45 2020
            2.08G scanned out of 389T at 142M/s, (scan is slow, no
    estimated time)
        86.7M resilvered, 0.00% done
    config:

            NAME                           STATE     READ WRITE CKSUM
            drpool04                       DEGRADED     0     0     0
              raidz2-0                     ONLINE       0     0     0
                c0t5000C500A7174C1Bd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   2
                c0t5000C500A7166DBBd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   3
                c0t5000C500A715FB3Bd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   4
                c0t5000C500A71BA81Bd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   5
                c0t5000C500A716D993d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   6
                c0t5000C500A717C8BFd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   7
                c0t5000C500A709DDFBd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   8
                c0t5000C500A71976E7d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |   9
                c0t5000C500A716CB5Fd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  10
                c0t5000C500A7193247d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  11
                c0t5000C500A7196AF3d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  12
                c0t5000C500A716578Fd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  13
                c0t5000C500A7174387d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  14
                c0t5000C500A71CFB77d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  15
              raidz2-1                     ONLINE       0     0     0
                c0t5000C500A717F117d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  16
                c0t5000C500A7161D3Fd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  17
                c0t5000C500A687FDA7d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  18
                c0t5000C500A6865B7Fd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  19
                c0t5000C500A7192253d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  20
                c0t5000C500A719770Fd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  21
                c0t5000C500A714668Fd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  22
                c0t5000C500A71E23F7d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  23
                c0t5000C500A715EF3Bd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  24
                c0t5000C500A71BAE9Bd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  25
                c0t5000C500A717BD6Bd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  26
                c0t5000C500A71B91E7d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  27
                c0t5000C500A716881Bd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  28
                c0t5000C500A6865B17d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  29
              raidz2-2                     DEGRADED     0     0     0
                c0t5000C500A716FA4Bd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  30
                c0t5000C500A688424Bd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  31
                c0t5000C500A716DA2Fd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  32
                spare-3                    DEGRADED     0     0     0
                  c0t5000C500A7192247d0    FAULTED      0     0     0
     external device fault
                  replacing-1              ONLINE       0     0     0
    c0t5000C500A71CEEFFd0  ONLINE       0     0     0   |
    MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  44
    c0t5000C500AE8296AFd0  ONLINE       0     0     0 |
    MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  90
                c0t5000C500A71919F7d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  34
                c0t5000C500A717C6B7d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  35
                c0t5000C500A716CE77d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  36
                c0t5000C500A6CA7707d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  37
                c0t5000C500A71BB05Bd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  38
    1685164993699279407        FAULTED    0     0     0  was
    /dev/dsk/c0t5000C500A71CEEFFd0s0
                c0t5000C500A71DD4A7d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  40
                c0t5000C500A718431Bd0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  41
                c0t5000C500A6866C13d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  42
                c0t5000C500A7148C97d0      ONLINE       0     0     0
      | MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  43
            spares
              c0t5000C500A716C0F3d0        AVAIL              |
    MIR-DR-RAID90-1_25717 |  45

    errors: No known data errors

    Notice the corresponding device IDs.   It's almost like a spare
    was used twice.

    Any suggestions on how to fix this?

    -Chip





*illumos <https://illumos.topicbox.com/latest>* / illumos-discuss / see discussions <https://illumos.topicbox.com/groups/discuss> + participants <https://illumos.topicbox.com/groups/discuss/members> + delivery options <https://illumos.topicbox.com/groups/discuss/subscription> Permalink <https://illumos.topicbox.com/groups/discuss/Tc5bd41589c784fed-M5e57fe0955be25e4a67cc611>

------------------------------------------
illumos: illumos-discuss
Permalink: 
https://illumos.topicbox.com/groups/discuss/Tc5bd41589c784fed-Mc46c0be91db9363d2d6bba9a
Delivery options: https://illumos.topicbox.com/groups/discuss/subscription

Reply via email to