Hi, The use cases draft made lot of things clearer to me. I went through the document, and have a few comments. I have not followed the recent discussions in the list since my membership had some issues, so ignore if some of my comments are already covered in the list or obvious.
1. B6 and B7 look the same. 2. B11: The sentence 'Beth administers her identitier' is not very clear? Probably an example using email or URL as an identifier can help here. 3. B12: (internet cafe case) Should we call out that that she first has to authenticate with her identity agent? 4. B13: Can we have an example of a simple privacy policy here, so this becomes clearer? 5. B14: Can the identity agent also do a similar operation if the user wants to discontinue her relationship with a particular service (should the agent be able to carry out the deprovisioning/deleting of the user information stored at the service site)? 6. B16: The identity agent should present the membership claim, not the user. 7. B21: The relationship of the identity agent to the site acting as agency for the bank account is not clear. 8. B27: The last sentence is not very clear. Does it mean "the site can verify Adam is over 21 but cannot get any other details of Adam including who he is (anonymous transaction?)"? 9. B29 and B30: I understood these use-cases to mean that a user can use either the same identifier(B29) or the same claim(B30) to different sites to enable them to correlate that it is the same user using their services. Is that a right understanding? 10. Can the user have more than one identity agent? Is this an allowed scenario, for which use cases are required? Imagine a organization-recommened identity agent, and a personal choice? Thanks and Regards, Haripriya S. >>> John Merrells <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> 04/10/06 11:46 PM >>> Based on feedback and contributed text I've revised the draft use cases document. Added: 1) More browser based use cases. In particular many examples of 'claims'. 2) Rob and Lisa's non- bowser based use cases. 3) Brief introductory section on goals of the group. Further comments / contributions are most welcome. John _______________________________________________ dix mailing list [email protected] https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dix
