On 6/29/25 1:25 AM, Alessandro Vesely wrote:
Let me remind you there were discussions and changes in November and
January. All the issues were closed. At that point the draft was
considered ready, until the surprise closure in March.
Those changes were made in preparation for the Working Group wrap-up.
And let's be clear, that wrap-up was not a surprise - Murray had been
very clear about his intentions and the timeline. Despite that, we
didn't get it submitted for the broader review process that leads to
publication.
Looking at the draft I don't see it as especially "incomplete," but ...
The Privacy Considerations section is a significant portion of the main
document (excluding the appendix), and spells out the exposure of
forwarding / mailing list membership. But are there other privacy
considerations that haven't been documented?
The DDoS potential is mentioned in section 5 and at the end of 2 -- does
that need to be mentioned explicitly in Security Considerations? Does it
need to be mentioned in the Introduction, as PII is?
What else is lacking?
--S.
_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
