On Tue, Jun 9, 2026 at 12:19 PM Matteo Contrini <matteo=
[email protected]> wrote:

> If the DMARC mechanism applies, then standard DMARC validation can take
> place, and if the message fails DMARC validation, then the governing DMARC
> policy record would apply, with that record's p or sp tag (if it exists)
> expressing the domain owner's handling preference.
>
> Isn't that precisely the problem here? A domain owner has the expectation
> that "np" would be used in this case, not "p" or "sp". NXDOMAIN and NSEC
> NXNAME mean the exact same thing, i.e. that the domain is non-existent, so
> "np" should apply in both cases.
>
> If the DMARC spec, and therefore implementors, don't take this into
> account, isn't this an interoperability issue, especially now that RFC 9824
> is a Proposed Standard with already significant real-world usage (see
> Cloudflare, NS1, etc.)?
>
> I know it's way too late to raise this, but I'm wondering if this can
> either fit as an erratum or if we can agree it's something the WG should
> take into consideration in the next DMARC revision (if any, and likely in a
> decade :-)).
>

Forgive me, as I've not been aware of RFC 9824 prior to this thread, and
I'm having a bit of trouble wrapping my head around it.

Am I to understand that RFC 9824 allows for the NODATA response to
"[claim] that
the name exists but doesn't have any data for the queried record type" but
to include in that response the setting of the NXNAME bit to state that the
claim that the name exists is false, because the name really doesn't exist?
Do I have that right?

As RFC 9989 is currently written, a domain owner wanting "np" to apply for
non-existent subdomains would seemingly want to ensure that they're not
using Compact Denial of Existence for their domains at this time, as RFC
9989 makes it clear that non-existent domain in the DMARC context is
consistent with the term's meaning in RFC 8020.

Alternatively, the domain owner can use the Compact Denial of Existence but
also ensure that the sp or p tags have the same value as the np tag, so
that if a non-existent domain isn't seen as such due to a 9824 response, a
DMARC failure would still be treated as desired.

-- 
Todd
_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to