All,

As mentiomed over on Mailop, I've come up with some code to poll the Umbrella 
1m (plus the root zone and the public suffix list) for adoption of t= as well 
as pct=, so that administrators can determine when they feel ready to tell 
their dmarc-checkers to stop honoring the pct= field.

I'm choosing to leave parsing of pct= in-place in the next release of OpenDMARC 
but make it user-configurable, to not violate POLA.  

In the top 10,000 u1m domains, I found about 30 with pct=0, including several 
major corporate ones (ciscospark.com, several shopify domains) and a NY state 
university (sunysb.edu) that have non-p=none policies.  Is this a small amount? 
 Probably.  But it's nonzero.

My polling scripts are in OpenDMARC/contrib on the develop branch.  I'm 
planning to put up a website for this at some point shortly with pretty graphs 
to track this over time.

Just because I find it interesting and I'm already running the DNS queries, I 
also report on:

* Domains with pct= where it would not make sense.

* How many RUA's post third-party consent records per 9990 section 4 (or 7489 
SS 7.1)

* How many domains in the u1m have dmarc records further up in the parent 
(presence in the u1m is obviously not an indicator that a domain originates 
mail).

  Domains queried : 1000003
  Errors          : 7146
  Have DMARC      : 110676 (11.1%)
  Have pct=       : 33737 (30.5% of DMARC)
  Have psd=       : 19 (0.0% of DMARC)
    psd=y         : 3
    psd=n         : 16
  Have t=         : 168 (0.2% of DMARC)
    t=y           : 25
    t=n           : 143
  p=reject/quarantine with pct=100 (no-op) : 22647
  p=none with pct= (no effect)             : 8323
RFC 7489 S 7.1 external reporting consent (dmarc-pct-survey-2026-06-25.tsv):
  Pairs checked               : 74346
  Domains w/ unconsented rua= : 9511
  Domains w/ unconsented ruf= : 5067
Parent-label walk (dmarc-pct-survey-2026-06-25-extra.tsv):
  Unlisted parents checked : 2101
  Unlisted parents w/DMARC : 163

(unlisted in this case means "is not in the u1m")

-Dan

_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to