John R Levine writes:
> Aw, come on.   Trent's draft explains why ARC failed.  I realize you don't 
> agree with it but I'm pretty sure you're in the rough here.

Trent's draft does explain why ARC failed when you apply goals that
were not listed in the ARC RFC. I think ARC did fullfill the goals
listed in the the ARC RFC.

> As I would have thought everyone here was aware, DKIM2 sort of combines 
> DKIM and ARC to provide a chain of custody that receievers can verify 
> without having to trust any of the signers at intermediate hops not to 
> lie.

DKIM2 combines few bad ideas from ARC, but makes them worse.

Trent's draft complains there is no trust in ARC because there is no
global reputation system.

DKIM2 expands this to say that there might be some kind of way of
saying which kind of changes done to the mail are acceptable and which
are not.

It is ok for the mailing list to add footer to emails it passes
through? Most likely most people say yes.

Is it ok for the mailing list like add advertisement for the next
event related to the mailing list (like IETF mailing list adding
footer telling that IETF 126 will be in Vienna in July 18-24? Some
people might say yes, some might say no.

Is it ok for the mailing list to add note well type text for every
single mail adding few kilobytes of the legal text to each email? I
think quite a lot of people would say nope. Legal people would say
they have to do it...

Is it ok for the mailing list to add few random advertiments to emails
it forwards to list subscribers. I think lots of people will say no.

DKIM2 somehow has to decide which one of those hanges are going to be
ok and which are not. I do not think that if we take 10 random people
we can't make them to agree which one of those are acceptable, but
DKIM2 thinks it is something it can do (perhaps automatically, perhaps
using some kind of AI or somehing).

Another thing with DKIM2 is the problem that it needs to be
implemented in every single email mail transmission agent. If they
can't do DKIM2 the chain will get broken (if I have understood
correctly), and end to end DKIM2 chain is broken and we do not get any
benefit from DKIM2.

In ARC it was enough if the system end user trusted did ARC and that
offered benefits for the end user. This is much easier deployment than
what is required for DKIM2.
-- 
[email protected]

_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to