What have I learned from studying my ARC data?   I have learned:

   - That when Outlook.Com acts as a submission server, it creates an ARC
   set which falsely asserts SPF Pass, DKIM Pass, and DMARC Pass, even though
   none of these tests actually occurred and no signatures are present in the
   message.


   - That when Outlook.Com acts as an outbound gateway, it creates an ARC
   set which accurately reports results of SPF, DKIM, and DMARC tests, but
   ignores all failures and accepts the message anyway.   It then adds a
   client DKIM signature to the message, as if identity had been verified.  It
   acts as if it is easily spoofed.  Does it have hidden controls which
   prevent spoofing?   I don't know.   I have a few examples which suggest
   that they are vulnerable to impersonation by this path, but not as many
   examples as I would expect if the vulnerability were really present.


   - That when Outlook.Com hands off messages to any of several outbound
   gateway services, those services also ignore evidence of authentication
   failure in the ARC set, and add a client DKIM signature anyway.


   - That when any of several outbound gateway services add a client DKIM
   signature to a message, they make probably-unintended changes to the
   message, and those changes break the ARC chain.


   - That most of those outbound gateway services have been unresponsive or
   unconcerned when informed that their DKIM signature additions were breaking
   the ARC chain.


   - That when legitimate senders have compromised accounts, outbound
   gateway services fail to block fraudulent messages which inbound gateway
   services detect easily.


   - That outbound gateway services add risk to the evaluation problem,
   rather than reducing it.


   - That ARC has shown how many infrastructure providers expect more trust
   than they earn.

With ARC, I am informed, but cynical.   Without ARC, I would be blissfully
ignorant.  Which is better?   On balance, I am glad that I have studied the
data which ARC provides, even though it has left me jaded.

Does that mean ARC is worth keeping around for a while?    I guess so.

Doug Foster
_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to