On Wed 08/Jul/2026 14:59:51 +0200 Brotman, Alex wrote:
I’ve said before that there may be some use for ARC (internal routing, etc),
Hm... The RFC mentions internal routing in Section 7.1.2, Multi-tier MTA Processing. I (a tiny MBP) cannot understand why a large MBP would need encryption to exchange Authentication-Results between different tiers. Yet, large MBPs implementing ARC typically include a plethora of ARC sets. Is there a reason for this?
but as the document describes the goals/usages of ARC, I don’t believe it is the solution we are looking for.
No, wait, we are not actually looking for a solution here, are we? AFAIK, we're looking for the reasons why the ARC experiment failed to scale up. The draft seems to only explore where DKIM2 walks over ARC deficiencies, and then conclude that DKIM2 will succeed. This is not helpful, IMHO. What is the draft trying to achieve?
At the time, the DMARC charter mentioned indirect mail flows, presumably referring to mailing lists and other forwarding cases. Wasn't this the goal? Yet, Section 7.1.3, Mailing Lists, of the RFC is very vague about the problem and what its solution might be. Was it already clear that ARC wouldn't have solved the mailing list problem? Anyway, at that point the WG quickly turned to the next phase, to specify the DMARC protocol.
Should we conduct a survey of mailing list operators asking them why they did or did not deploy ARC? And perhaps even asking what kind of solution would they consider?
Best Ale -- _______________________________________________ dmarc mailing list -- [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
