Murray S. Kucherawy writes:
> On Tue, Aug 11, 2026 at 4:30 AM Alessandro Vesely <[email protected]> wrote:
> 
>     Having "Internet-scale" and "reputation" in the same sentence also puzzles
>     me.
>     It seems to suggest that domain reputation can somehow propagate through
>     the
>     Internet.
> 
> To me, "reputation" is the opinion you've developed about a signer
> or sender or domain or whatever you're keying on, while

You said it exactly correctly when you said it is "opinion you've
developed", i.e., something that final recipient, the person, an
agent, or filtering script acting on behalf of the user has developed. 

> "Internet-scale" means developing or applying reputation to very
> large mail flows like those seen at Gmail or Yahoo.

There is no such thing that Internet-scale reputation. There is no way
all users in the internet would agree on the reputation of anything.

Some users spam is another users newsletter and vice versa. And those
two users might be in the same mail service providers.

Exactly same thing with ARC signers. Most of you have no reason to
trust ARC signatures signed by iki.fi, because that server is not
meaningfull for you.

On the other hand, as I am a member (and one of the adminstrators) of
iki.fi non profit, I can trust it to correctly generate authentication
results on the emails when it receives them, thus I can use those as
an input when I do my filtering.

> Accurate reputation development improves the quality of service you
> can provide.  Accordingly, individual operators (of varying sizes)
> develop and keep this reputation entirely within their systems, and
> as far as I know it is never shared.

Reputation is not developed for the operators, it really needs to be
for the users. I.e., even in the same mail service provider the two
users might have completely different view of the reputation of the
different senders/signers/domains.
-- 
[email protected]

_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to